Chiel Laura E, Fishman Michael, Driessen Erik, Winn Ariel S
Division of Pulmonary Medicine, Department of Pediatrics, Boston Children's Hospital and Harvard Medical School, 300 Longwood Ave., Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, MA 02115, US.
School of Health Professions Education (SHE), Maastricht University, Maastricht, NL.
Perspect Med Educ. 2025 Feb 14;14(1):66-73. doi: 10.5334/pme.1654. eCollection 2025.
Advanced training experiences are required in certain countries for subspecialization. In the United States, a decline in Milestones and in levels of supervision for Entrustable Professional Activities for incoming subspecialty fellows has been described and attributed to changes in context that fellows experience. We aimed to explore this transition to advanced training, and specifically to describe which contextual factors are salient to fellows at the residency to fellowship transition and the supports available for a smooth transition to fellowship.
Using contextual competence as a sensitizing concept, ten semi-structured interviews with first- and second-year pediatric subspecialty fellows from three subspecialties were performed at a large academic medical center in 2023, using thematic analysis informed by elements of constructivist grounded theory.
Contextual factors that impacted the transition included changes in systems, necessary knowledge, and roles and responsibilities. At times, participants describe a tension between feeling like novices while simultaneously feeling like they should have more expertise than they had. Supports in navigating this tension, and in navigating the transition more generally, included formal orientations, fellow behaviors and perspective, and input from others.
The transition to advanced training is characterized, at times, by experiencing tension between feeling like a novice while feeling like one should have expertise, with fellows' own behaviors and the support of those around them being essential to fellows' smooth transition. While fellowship programs offer orientations, systems-level solutions for supporting fellows' navigation of the transition are underexplored.
在某些国家,专科培训需要有高级培训经历。在美国,有描述称住院医师培训中的“里程碑”以及新入职专科培训学员的可托付专业活动的监督水平有所下降,并将其归因于学员所经历的环境变化。我们旨在探讨向高级培训的这一转变,特别是描述哪些环境因素对从住院医师向专科培训学员转变的学员而言是显著的,以及有哪些支持措施可助力顺利过渡到专科培训。
以情境胜任力作为一个敏感概念,2023年在一家大型学术医疗中心对来自三个专科的一年级和二年级儿科专科培训学员进行了十次半结构化访谈,采用建构主义扎根理论要素指导下的主题分析方法。
影响转变的环境因素包括系统变化、必要知识以及角色和职责。有时,参与者描述了一种矛盾的感受,既觉得自己像新手,同时又觉得自己应该比实际拥有更多的专业知识。帮助应对这种矛盾以及更全面地应对转变的支持措施包括正式的入职培训、学员的行为和观点,以及他人的建议。
向高级培训的转变有时的特点是,一方面感觉自己像新手,另一方面又觉得自己应该具备专业知识,这两者之间存在矛盾,学员自身的行为以及周围人的支持对于学员顺利过渡至关重要。虽然专科培训项目提供入职培训,但对于支持学员过渡的系统层面的解决方案,尚未得到充分探索。