Bullington Brooke W, Lyleroehr Madison, Berg Kristen A, White Kari, Boozer Margaret, Serna Tania, Miller Emily S, Bailit Jennifer L, Arora Kavita Shah
Department of Epidemiology, Gillings School of Global Public Health, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA.
Carolina Population Center, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA.
Perspect Sex Reprod Health. 2025 Mar;57(1):63-71. doi: 10.1111/psrh.70000. Epub 2025 Feb 21.
Given the history of coercion in the provision of sterilization, it is important that patients who desire permanent contraception receive patient-centered care that respects their preferences. Recent literature examining the provision of postpartum permanent contraception has not explored whether patients who desire permanent contraception feel supported by their clinical teams.
We interviewed patients from four medical centers around the United States with a documented desire for postpartum permanent contraception. We audio-recorded, transcribed, and analyzed interviews using rapid qualitative methods and thematic content analysis.
Of the 81 patients interviewed, most (n = 64) felt supported by their clinician throughout their prenatal care and delivery hospitalization. Seventeen patients shared stories of feeling unsupported. Patients recalled feeling dismissed when they initiated conversations about permanent contraception. Additionally, they felt they had received incomplete counseling on permanent contraception and felt discouraged from getting the procedure during prenatal care encounters. During delivery hospitalization, patients discussed not being informed about barriers to permanent contraception as they surfaced, facing lack of prioritization of the procedure by clinicians, recognizing communications errors among the clinical team, and feeling pressured to undergo or not undergo permanent contraception.
Most patients felt supported by their clinicians throughout permanent contraception decision-making and provision. Patients who did not feel supported reported a spectrum of experiences ranging from rushed appointments, perceived clinician bias in counseling, and communications barriers to the provision of permanent contraception after delivery. Patient-centered care that prioritizes patient experiences, values, and desires is necessary to ensure that all people can achieve their reproductive goals.
鉴于绝育手术实施过程中存在强迫历史,对于希望采取永久性避孕措施的患者而言,接受以患者为中心、尊重其偏好的护理至关重要。近期有关产后永久性避孕措施提供情况的文献尚未探讨希望采取永久性避孕措施的患者是否感到得到了临床团队的支持。
我们采访了美国四个医疗中心有记录表明希望采取产后永久性避孕措施的患者。我们使用快速定性方法和主题内容分析法对访谈进行了录音、转录和分析。
在接受采访的81名患者中,大多数(n = 64)在整个产前护理和分娩住院期间都感到得到了临床医生的支持。17名患者分享了感到未得到支持的经历。患者回忆说,当他们开始谈论永久性避孕措施时,感觉被忽视了。此外,他们觉得自己在永久性避孕方面得到的咨询不完整,并且在产前护理过程中感到进行该手术受到了阻碍。在分娩住院期间,患者们谈到,随着永久性避孕措施相关障碍的出现,他们未得到相关告知,面临临床医生对该手术的不重视,意识到临床团队之间存在沟通失误,并且在是否进行永久性避孕方面感到有压力。
大多数患者在整个永久性避孕决策和实施过程中都感到得到了临床医生的支持。未感到得到支持的患者报告了一系列经历,从预约匆忙、在咨询中察觉到临床医生的偏见、沟通障碍到分娩后永久性避孕措施的提供问题。以患者为中心、优先考虑患者体验、价值观和愿望的护理对于确保所有人都能实现其生殖目标是必要的。