Çelik Göksu, Healy Schylar Alexandra, Stolte Stefan, Mayer Philipp, Markiewicz Marta
Dresden University of Technology, Institute of Water Chemistry, Bergstr. 66, D-01062 Dresden, Germany.
University of Vienna, Centre for Microbiology and Environmental Systems Science, Environmental Geosciences EDGE, 1090 Vienna, Austria.
Environ Sci Technol. 2025 May 13;59(18):8984-8996. doi: 10.1021/acs.est.5c00384. Epub 2025 Apr 30.
Testing the bioaccumulation and chronic toxicity of (highly) hydrophobic compounds is extremely challenging, but crucial for hazard assessment. Fish are used as a model organism in these tests, but have many limitations, including a long time to reach steady-state, difficulty in maintaining constant exposure, and ethical concerns. We developed a method for the (simultaneous) assessment of chronic reproductive toxicity and bioaccumulation using as a model organism. As test chemicals, we selected heterocyclic polyaromatic hydrocarbons (heterocyclic PAHs), which are often persistent and show high acute aquatic toxicity, raising concerns about their long-term effects. In this study, we developed a robust passive dosing method to maintain constant exposure in chronic toxicity and bioaccumulation tests of four heterocyclic PAHs in . Passive dosing maintained stable exposure concentrations in the ng to μg L range, even after reusing disks up to three times. All chemicals were toxic to with EC values between 0.1 and 15 μg L. Bioaccumulation tests showed that steady-state was not reached, and the uptake rate constant () could not be reliably determined due to complex exposure routes (both via water and diet). However, depuration rates in were about 2 orders of magnitude higher than in fish, which is advantageous in the assessment of highly hydrophobic compounds. We propose to use the depuration rate constant (), which is independent of the uptake route, as an indicator of bioaccumulation potential. The thresholds for were estimated to identify (very) bioaccumulative compounds by correlating values with bioconcentration factors (BCFs) for and applying fish BCF thresholds. We suggest that a bioaccumulation test can be used as a screening tool to trigger further bioaccumulation testing in fish, as it offers higher throughput, is more ethical, and reaches steady-state faster. However, further validation with reference test protocols and substances is essential.
测试(高度)疏水性化合物的生物累积性和慢性毒性极具挑战性,但对于危害评估至关重要。在这些测试中,鱼类被用作模式生物,但存在许多局限性,包括达到稳态所需时间长、难以维持恒定暴露以及伦理问题。我们开发了一种使用[具体生物名称未给出]作为模式生物同时评估慢性生殖毒性和生物累积性的方法。作为测试化学品,我们选择了杂环多环芳烃(杂环PAHs),它们通常具有持久性且显示出高急性水生毒性,引发了对其长期影响的担忧。在本研究中,我们开发了一种稳健的被动给药方法,以在[具体生物名称未给出]对四种杂环PAHs的慢性毒性和生物累积性测试中维持恒定暴露。被动给药在纳克至微克/升范围内维持了稳定的暴露浓度,即使圆盘重复使用多达三次。所有化学品对[具体生物名称未给出]均有毒性,其EC值在0.1至15微克/升之间。生物累积性测试表明未达到稳态,并且由于复杂的暴露途径(通过水和食物),摄取速率常数([具体符号未给出])无法可靠确定。然而,[具体生物名称未给出]的净化速率比鱼类高约2个数量级,这在评估高度疏水性化合物时具有优势。我们建议使用与摄取途径无关的净化速率常数([具体符号未给出])作为生物累积潜力的指标。通过将[具体生物名称未给出]的[具体数值未给出]值与生物浓缩因子(BCFs)相关联并应用鱼类BCF阈值,估计了[具体生物名称未给出]的阈值以识别(非常)生物累积性化合物。我们建议[具体生物名称未给出]生物累积性测试可作为一种筛选工具,以触发在鱼类中进行进一步的生物累积性测试,因为它具有更高的通量、更符合伦理且达到稳态更快。然而,使用参考测试方案和物质进行进一步验证至关重要。