UFMylation is a ubiquitin-like protein modification of Ubiquitin Fold Modifier 1 (UFM1) applied to substrate proteins and regulates several cellular processes such as protein quality control. Here, we describe the development of an antibody-based enrichment approach to immunoprecipitate remnant UFMylated peptides and identification by mass spectrometry. We used this approach to identify >200 UFMylation sites from various mouse tissues, revealing extensive modification in skeletal muscle. In vivo knockdown of the E2 ligase, UFC1, followed by enrichment and analysis of remnant UFMylated peptides quantified concomitant down-regulation and validation of a subset of modification sites, particularly myosin UFMylation. Furthermore, we show that UFMylation is increased in skeletal muscle biopsies from people living with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (plwALS). Quantification of UFMylation sites in these biopsies with multiplexed isotopic labeling reveal prominent increases in myosin UFMylation. Our data suggest that in vivo UFMylation is more complex than previously thought.