Mehri Ahmad, Hashemi Nazari Seyed Saeed, Mostafavi Farideh, Rostami Varnousfaderani Mehran, Mahdavi Seyed Amirhosein, Haj-Manouchehri Reza, Mirotorabi Seyed Davood, Saberi Isfeedvajani Mohsen
Department of Epidemiology, School of Public Health and Safety, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Legal Medicine Research Center, Legal Medicine Organization, Tehran, Iran.
Arch Iran Med. 2025 Apr 1;28(4):207-216. doi: 10.34172/aim.31947.
The increasing demand for healthcare services and some associated factors including lack of physicians, lack of trust in physicians, ineffectiveness of treatments and high costs may be have led to a rise in non-physician-provided services. This study aims to assess health services delivery by non-physicians and its associated factors in Iran.
This study was a cross-sectional study conducted using a convenience sampling method in the Iranian community in 2023. A standard questionnaire with 45 questions was developed based on focus group discussions and a validation process to assess the status of receiving services in six medical areas including traditional medicine, abortion, traditional dentistry, obesity and slimming diets, bone setting, and addiction treatment. Data collection was carried out using online questionnaires on Iranian and non-Iranian social media platforms. Descriptive and analytical statistics were used to analyze the data, with logistic regression adjusting for various demographic factors.
Out of 1713 participants, 53.9% (95% CI: 51.5%-56.3%) were women, and the majority were in the 30-40 age group. Traditional Islamic medicine was the most commonly sought service, with 56% (95% CI: 51.2%-60.8%) of users receiving it from non-physicians. Satisfaction with non-physician services varied, with 32.1% (95% CI: 25.8%-38.4%) reporting high satisfaction for traditional medicine, but only 49.4% (95% CI: 40.5%-58.3%) for experimental dentistry. Key reasons for choosing non-physician providers included the effectiveness of traditional treatments and fear of modern medicine's side effects.
The result showed that the use of non-physician services can be considerable and that necessary interventions should be designed to standardize treatments and deal with substandard providers who may be harmful to the health of the community.
对医疗服务的需求不断增加,以及一些相关因素,包括医生短缺、对医生缺乏信任、治疗效果不佳和成本高昂,可能导致非医生提供的服务有所增加。本研究旨在评估伊朗非医生提供的医疗服务及其相关因素。
本研究是一项横断面研究,于2023年在伊朗社区采用便利抽样方法进行。基于焦点小组讨论和验证过程,开发了一份包含45个问题的标准问卷,以评估在六个医疗领域接受服务的情况,包括传统医学、堕胎、传统牙科、肥胖与减肥饮食、正骨和成瘾治疗。通过伊朗和非伊朗社交媒体平台上的在线问卷进行数据收集。使用描述性和分析性统计方法对数据进行分析,并通过逻辑回归对各种人口统计学因素进行调整。
在1713名参与者中,53.9%(95%置信区间:51.5%-56.3%)为女性,大多数处于30-40岁年龄组。传统伊斯兰医学是最常寻求的服务,56%(95%置信区间:51.2%-60.8%)的使用者从非医生处接受该服务。对非医生服务的满意度各不相同,32.1%(95%置信区间:25.8%-38.4%)的人对传统医学表示高度满意,但对实验性牙科仅为49.4%(95%置信区间:40.5%-58.3%)。选择非医生提供者的主要原因包括传统治疗的有效性以及对现代医学副作用的恐惧。
结果表明,非医生服务的使用可能相当可观,应设计必要的干预措施,以规范治疗,并应对可能对社区健康有害的不合格提供者。