Oliphant Stephen N, Zeoli April M
Institute for Firearm Injury Prevention, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI.
Department of Health Management and Policy, School of Public Health, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI.
Criminol Public Policy. 2024 Nov;23(4):893-918. doi: 10.1111/1745-9133.12677. Epub 2024 Jun 21.
While federal law prohibits firearm possession by individuals who have been convicted of a disqualifying offense and those who are subject to certain domestic violence protective orders (DVPOs), it does not provide a mechanism for enforcing firearm dispossession. Some states have adopted relinquishment laws to enforce firearm possession restrictions among prohibited persons following a disqualifying status or conviction. To date, limited research has assessed the statutory characteristics of firearm relinquishment laws related to DVPOs. We build on this work by assessing DVPO and conviction-based relinquishment statutes, including legislative changes over time, to identify gaps in policy.
Our analysis revealed that many states still lack statutory elements that are expected to increase the likelihood of firearm dispossession, such as requiring the court to order relinquishment, strict standards for providing proof of firearm transfer or some form of compliance verification, and provisions that authorize law enforcement to recover unrelinquished firearms. The absence of such elements may facilitate unlawful firearm retention by those who become prohibited possessors. States might consider adopting relinquishment provisions that outline clear requirements for actors (i.e., judges, prohibited possessors, law enforcement) at each stage of the process to ensure that firearms are relinquished following a disqualifying conviction or DVPO.
虽然联邦法律禁止被判定犯有不合格罪行的个人以及受到某些家庭暴力保护令(DVPO)约束的人持有枪支,但它并未提供执行枪支没收的机制。一些州已通过交出枪支的法律,以在禁止人员出现不合格身份或被定罪后执行枪支持有限制。迄今为止,有限的研究评估了与DVPO相关的枪支交出法律的法定特征。我们在此基础上开展工作,评估基于DVPO和定罪的交出枪支法规,包括随时间的立法变化,以找出政策中的差距。
我们的分析表明,许多州仍然缺乏预期会增加枪支被没收可能性的法定要素,例如要求法院下令交出枪支、提供枪支转让证明或某种形式合规核查的严格标准,以及授权执法部门收缴未交出枪支的条款。这些要素的缺失可能会便利那些成为被禁止持枪者的人非法保留枪支。各州可以考虑采用交出枪支的条款,明确规定在该过程的每个阶段对相关行为方(即法官、被禁止持枪者、执法部门)的要求,以确保在出现不合格定罪或DVPO后交出枪支。