Miller Paul K, Bowden Samantha Lj, Dewison Natalie, Ingham Barry, Thwaites Richard, Dagnan Dave
University of Cumbria, UK.
Lancashire and South Cumbria NHS Foundation Trust, UK.
Autism. 2025 May 22:13623613251341610. doi: 10.1177/13623613251341610.
Autistic people are more likely to experience mental health problems such as anxiety disorder and depression than are the general population. This study reports a qualitative analysis of interview data provided by 12 psychological therapists regarding their experiences of working with autistic people with anxiety disorders and/or depression within a structured primary care mental health service in the north of England. Interviews were analysed using thematic analysis. Four main themes were identified: (1) Experience and Trepidation, (2) Wrong Service, Only Service, (3) Therapeutic Environment and (4) Training and Adaptations. Participating therapists identified challenges in the structure of the services they worked in, the applicability of conventional therapies and the need for autism-specific therapy training ideally led by autistic people. Centrally, participants did not routinely feel fully equipped to separate endemic aspects of autism itself from features of a mental health disorder in an autistic person, which had left some feeling powerless to help in certain cases, or as if they may have done more harm than good. All participants were, however, able to identify positive adaptations made from practical experience, and most reported a growing confidence in working with autistic people.Lay AbstractWe are a group of autistic people, academic researchers and psychological therapists, with some of us being more than one of those things. We started from the knowledge that autistic people are particularly prone to have anxiety disorders and depression. We were, therefore, interested in how current 'talking therapy' services in England might, or might not, be helping autistic people with those problems. To address this issue, we interviewed 12 psychological therapists in the north of England who had experience of working with autistic people with an anxiety disorder, depression or both. We found that the therapists often felt that they were not prepared or trained to give autistic people their best service. The therapists were also concerned that some of the therapies they usually applied did not always work with autistic people, or sometimes even made things worse. They felt it was important, however, that autistic people should keep using the service, as there was no other service available to them if they had an anxiety disorder or depression. There was evidence, however, that talking therapies still had positive effects for autistic people, and that therapists had therefore probably underestimated their positive impact in a lot of cases. Consequently, training was recommended such that psychological therapists might better understand mental health and specific therapy adaptations that help autistic people.
与普通人群相比,自闭症患者更有可能经历诸如焦虑症和抑郁症等心理健康问题。本研究报告了一项定性分析,该分析基于12位心理治疗师提供的访谈数据,内容涉及他们在英格兰北部一个结构化的初级保健心理健康服务机构中,与患有焦虑症和/或抑郁症的自闭症患者合作的经历。访谈采用主题分析法进行分析。确定了四个主要主题:(1)经验与恐惧,(2)错误的服务,唯一的服务,(3)治疗环境,以及(4)培训与调整。参与研究的治疗师指出了他们工作的服务结构方面的挑战、传统疗法的适用性,以及理想情况下由自闭症患者主导的针对自闭症的治疗培训的必要性。核心问题是,参与者通常感觉没有充分的能力将自闭症本身的固有特征与自闭症患者心理健康障碍的特征区分开来,这使得一些人在某些情况下感到无力提供帮助,或者觉得自己可能弊大于利。然而,所有参与者都能够确定从实际经验中做出的积极调整,并且大多数人报告称在与自闭症患者合作时信心不断增强。
摘要
我们是一群自闭症患者、学术研究人员和心理治疗师,我们中的一些人身兼数职。我们从自闭症患者特别容易患焦虑症和抑郁症这一认识出发。因此,我们对英格兰目前的“谈话疗法”服务如何可能或不可能帮助患有这些问题的自闭症患者很感兴趣。为了解决这个问题,我们采访了英格兰北部12位有与患有焦虑症、抑郁症或两者兼有的自闭症患者合作经验的心理治疗师。我们发现,治疗师常常觉得他们没有准备好或没有接受过培训,无法为自闭症患者提供最佳服务。治疗师还担心他们通常采用的一些疗法对自闭症患者并不总是有效,或者有时甚至会使情况变得更糟。然而,他们认为自闭症患者应该继续使用这项服务很重要,因为如果他们患有焦虑症或抑郁症,没有其他服务可供他们选择。然而,有证据表明谈话疗法对自闭症患者仍然有积极影响,因此治疗师在很多情况下可能低估了其积极作用。因此,建议进行培训,以便心理治疗师能够更好地理解心理健康以及有助于自闭症患者的特定治疗调整。