Hilton Aidan, Jerjes Waseem
Department of Primary Care and Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, Imperial College London, London W12 0BZ, UK.
Clin Pract. 2025 May 13;15(5):94. doi: 10.3390/clinpract15050094.
AIMS/BACKGROUND: Medical education is largely clinical and biomedical with little emphasis being put upon the social determinants of health (SDH) and patient-centredness. A programme entitled "Walking a Day in My Shoes" was devised as a pilot cohort study with the view of evaluating the impact of a clinical shadowing experience upon the empathy, SDH awareness, and patient-centredness of medical students.
A prospective cohort study, involving 28 final-year London-area medical students, employing a three-phase teaching programme comprising preparation, observation, and reflection was carried out. Students' confidence in the management of non-medical barriers, SDH awareness, and empathy before and after shadowing were measured using pre- and post-shadowing questionnaires. Qualitative analysis of patient feedback and journals also occurred.
Statistically significant improvements were observed in students' empathy (mean score increase from 6.8 to 8.9, < 0.001), understanding of SDH (advanced comprehension rose from 35% to 93%), confidence in addressing non-clinical barriers (from 39% to 86%), and awareness of logistical challenges (from 31% to 81%). Qualitative analysis highlighted key themes, including systemic barriers (transportation, polypharmacy, and social isolation) and students' increased awareness of the emotional toll of chronic illness. Patients expressed high satisfaction, with 97% agreeing that the programme improved students' understanding of chronic disease management. These findings suggest the programme's practicality and scalability in medical education.
This pilot cohort study demonstrated the significant enhancement of the students' empathy, perception of SDH, and patient-centredness preparation through immersive shadowing. The findings support the use of experiential learning programmes as curricular interventions.
目的/背景:医学教育主要侧重于临床和生物医学,很少关注健康的社会决定因素(SDH)以及以患者为中心的理念。一项名为“体验我的一天”的项目被设计为一项试点队列研究,旨在评估临床跟班体验对医学生同理心、对SDH的认知以及以患者为中心的理念的影响。
开展了一项前瞻性队列研究,涉及28名伦敦地区的医学专业最后一年学生,采用了一个包括准备、观察和反思的三阶段教学计划。通过跟班前后的问卷来测量学生在跟班前后对非医学障碍管理的信心、对SDH的认知以及同理心。还对患者反馈和日志进行了定性分析。
观察到学生在同理心(平均得分从6.8提高到8.9,<0.001)、对SDH的理解(深入理解从35%提高到93%)、应对非临床障碍的信心(从39%提高到86%)以及对后勤挑战的认知(从31%提高到81%)方面有统计学上的显著改善。定性分析突出了关键主题,包括系统性障碍(交通、多重用药和社会隔离)以及学生对慢性病情感负担的认识增加。患者表示高度满意,97%的患者认为该项目提高了学生对慢性病管理的理解。这些发现表明该项目在医学教育中的实用性和可扩展性。
这项试点队列研究表明,通过沉浸式跟班,学生的同理心、对SDH的认知以及以患者为中心的准备得到了显著提高。研究结果支持将体验式学习项目用作课程干预措施。