Suppr超能文献

赞比亚本科神经医学教育中翻转课堂教学法的评估

Evaluation of a flipped classroom approach to undergraduate neurology medical education in Zambia.

作者信息

Holroyd Kathryn B, McDonough Annie, Chomba Mashina, Asukile Melody, Chiwaya Ndonji, Vallejos Gerome, Asmare Samuel, Braun Sarah, Chishimba Lorraine, Gebrewold Meron A, Luchembe Musisye, Mulenga Bwalya, Mwamba Julia, Namangala Coolwe, Nassoro David, Peloso Alex, Yankae Leroy, Zimba Stanley, Berkowitz Aaron, Saylor Deanna

机构信息

Department of Neurology, Columbia University School of Medicine, New York, NY, USA.

Department of Neurology, University of California San Francisco School of Medicine, San Francisco, CA, USA.

出版信息

J Neurol Sci. 2025 Aug 15;475:123580. doi: 10.1016/j.jns.2025.123580. Epub 2025 Jun 11.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Countries in sub-Saharan Africa, including Zambia, have few neurologists, and neurophobia is common amongst medical trainees. While neurology teaching initiatives and training programs are growing in the region, innovative teaching methods are needed to improve neurology knowledge, reduce neurophobia, and encourage medical students to pursue careers in neurology. Furthermore, studies formally evaluating the effectiveness of different neurology teaching methods are needed.

METHODS

Fifth and seventh year undergraduate medical students on their internal medicine clinical clerkship were randomized by clerkship group (i.e. all students completing the clerkship in a given time period were randomized together) to either a traditional lecture or flipped classroom curriculum for delivery of the neurology content of their clerkship. In the traditional classroom arm, students attended in-person neurology lectures and accessed corresponding clinical case presentations online. In the flipped classroom arm, students watched pre-recorded neurology lectures, and class time was dedicated to interactive small group review of clinical cases. Students completed anonymous pre- and post-course surveys consisting of knowledge assessments, self-reported confidence in diagnosing/managing neurologic disorders, neurophobia surveys, and course satisfaction surveys. Pre-and post- course score differences and differences in change scores were compared between instructional models along with quantified effect sizes.

RESULTS

In total, 263 fifth year students (100 traditional, 163 flipped) and 99 seventh year students (48 traditional, 51 flipped) had complete data and were included in final analysis. A greater increase in knowledge assessment scores was observed in both the fifth and seventh year flipped classroom groups compared to the traditional groups (p < 0.01 for both). Both fifth and seventh year students in the flipped classroom groups also demonstrated a greater increase in confidence diagnosing and managing common neurologic conditions compared to students in the traditional groups. Flipped classroom students in both year groups reported significantly greater course satisfaction, effective learning, course participation, and course collaboration. Neurophobia scores significantly decreased only in the fifth year flipped classroom group.

CONCLUSIONS

A flipped classroom approach improved neurology knowledge, confidence diagnosing/managing neurologic disorders, and course satisfaction in Zambian medical students compared to traditional lectures. The flipped classroom approach may represent a promising pedagogical model for improving neurology education in similar resource-limited settings with few neurologists.

摘要

背景

包括赞比亚在内的撒哈拉以南非洲国家,神经科医生数量稀少,医学实习生中普遍存在神经恐惧症。尽管该地区的神经病学教学倡议和培训项目不断增加,但仍需要创新的教学方法来提高神经病学知识、减少神经恐惧症,并鼓励医学生从事神经病学职业。此外,需要开展正式评估不同神经病学教学方法有效性的研究。

方法

在内科临床实习的五年级和七年级本科医学生,按实习组(即所有在给定时间段内完成实习的学生一起随机分组)随机分为传统讲座组或翻转课堂组,以进行实习期间神经病学内容的授课。在传统课堂组,学生参加面对面的神经病学讲座,并在线访问相应的临床病例展示。在翻转课堂组,学生观看预先录制的神经病学讲座,课堂时间用于对临床病例进行互动式小组复习。学生完成匿名的课前和课后调查问卷,包括知识评估、自我报告的诊断/管理神经系统疾病的信心、神经恐惧症调查和课程满意度调查。比较两种教学模式之间的课前和课后分数差异以及变化分数差异,并计算量化效应量。

结果

共有263名五年级学生(100名传统组,163名翻转课堂组)和99名七年级学生(48名传统组,51名翻转课堂组)拥有完整数据并纳入最终分析。与传统组相比,五年级和七年级翻转课堂组的知识评估分数均有更大幅度的提高(两者p均<0.01)。与传统组的学生相比,翻转课堂组的五年级和七年级学生在诊断和管理常见神经系统疾病方面的信心也有更大幅度的提高。两个年级组的翻转课堂学生报告的课程满意度、有效学习、课程参与度和课程协作度均显著更高。仅五年级翻转课堂组的神经恐惧症分数显著降低。

结论

与传统讲座相比,翻转课堂教学法提高了赞比亚医学生的神经病学知识、诊断/管理神经系统疾病的信心以及课程满意度。翻转课堂教学法可能是一种有前景的教学模式,可用于在类似的资源有限且神经科医生稀缺的环境中改善神经病学教育。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验