Wood Francine, McLarnon Courtney, Smith Sarah, Yerabandi Nitya, McDougal Lotus
Stud Fam Plann. 2025 Sep;56(3):621-641. doi: 10.1111/sifp.70025. Epub 2025 Jul 9.
Improving women's agency in family planning is an integral component of empowerment, requiring culturally relevant, reliable, and valid measures. Measuring agency-action towards the achievement of self-determined goals-is key to tracking progress as highlighted by its inclusion in the Sustainable Development Goals. Yet, agency measurement within low- and middle-income contexts has all too often involved applying measures developed and tested in high-income contexts, and conceptual confusion has also led to both overlapping measures and those that omit key facets of agency. To examine the construction and application of agency measures in family planning research and programs, we conducted a scoping review of studies in low-and middle-income countries. Of 9,289 articles and abstracts screened, 72 met our inclusion criteria and included family planning outcomes. We identified 58 unique measures. Most measures were summative and described psychometric testing. Measures often included family planning-specific items, generally focused on contraceptive use with less attention to areas such as communication, access to services, or fertility timing. While increased interest in measuring family planning agency is evident, inconsistencies in measurement hinder cross-contextual comparisons. As family planning research and programs adopt empowerment-focused benchmarks, validated measures of agency are needed to accurately assess impact.
提高女性在计划生育方面的自主权是赋权的一个重要组成部分,这需要与文化相关、可靠且有效的措施。衡量朝着实现自主设定目标采取的行动——自主权是跟踪进展的关键,可持续发展目标将其纳入就凸显了这一点。然而,在低收入和中等收入背景下进行的自主权衡量往往涉及应用在高收入背景下开发和测试的措施,而且概念上的混乱还导致了衡量措施的重叠以及遗漏自主权关键方面的情况。为了研究计划生育研究和项目中自主权衡量措施的构建与应用,我们对低收入和中等收入国家的研究进行了一项范围审查。在筛选的9289篇文章和摘要中,有72篇符合我们的纳入标准并包含计划生育成果。我们识别出了58种独特的衡量措施。大多数衡量措施是总结性的,并描述了心理测量测试。这些措施通常包括计划生育特定项目,一般侧重于避孕措施的使用,而对沟通、服务获取或生育时间等领域关注较少。虽然对衡量计划生育自主权的兴趣明显增加,但衡量的不一致阻碍了跨背景比较。随着计划生育研究和项目采用以赋权为重点的基准,需要经过验证的自主权衡量措施来准确评估影响。