Barton Chris, Wouterlood Max, Selamoglu Melis, Madawala Sanduni, Enticott Joanne, Sturgiss Elizabeth, George Johnson, Borland Ron
School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, Melbourne, Australia.
Monash Centre for Health Research and Implementation, School of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, Clayton, VIC 3168, Australia.
Prim Health Care Res Dev. 2025 Jul 11;26:e56. doi: 10.1017/S1463423625100273.
We assessed patient experience of care, comparing current and past smokers, and whether frequency of advice to quit smoking impacts patient rating of care.
Experience of care may be a concern for people who smoke and affect their partnership with healthcare providers.
We surveyed adults aged over 35 years who had visited a general practitioner (GP) for health care in the past year (n = 611 current and n = 275 ex-smokers). Questions assessed smoking history, experience of care, anticipation of stigma, and perceptions of smoking cessation advice received in general practice.
Fewer than half (48.8%) of current smokers reported 'always' or 'usually' being advised to quit smoking, or being advised in a way that motivated them to quit by a GP or other care provider at their GP practice. Current smokers tended to delay or avoid help seeking when needed and experienced more anticipation of stigma in healthcare settings. Conversely, respondents who reported being advised to quit more frequently rated overall quality of care more highly. These data show that asking about smoking and providing advice to quit smoking was acceptable to most respondents and associated with higher ratings of quality of care. However, advice should be provided in a way that motivates patients, without exacerbating the stigma associated with smoking, which may impact help seeking.
我们评估了患者的就医体验,比较了当前吸烟者和既往吸烟者,以及戒烟建议的频率是否会影响患者对医疗服务的评分。
就医体验可能是吸烟者关注的问题,并影响他们与医疗服务提供者的关系。
我们对过去一年中因医疗保健而去看全科医生(GP)的35岁以上成年人进行了调查(611名当前吸烟者和275名既往吸烟者)。问题涉及吸烟史、就医体验、对耻辱感的预期以及在全科医疗中收到的戒烟建议的看法。
不到一半(48.8%)的当前吸烟者报告“总是”或“通常”被建议戒烟,或者以促使他们戒烟的方式被全科医生或其全科医疗实践中的其他护理提供者建议戒烟。当前吸烟者在需要时往往会推迟或避免寻求帮助,并且在医疗环境中更多地预期会受到耻辱。相反,报告更频繁地被建议戒烟的受访者对整体医疗质量的评价更高。这些数据表明,询问吸烟情况并提供戒烟建议对大多数受访者来说是可以接受的,并且与更高的医疗质量评分相关。然而,建议应以激励患者的方式提供,而不会加剧与吸烟相关的耻辱感,因为这可能会影响寻求帮助。