Sait Haseena, Adarsha Naik, Moirangthem Amita, Saxena Deepti, Sharma Lokesh, Dabadgao Preeti, Gupta Avantika, Phadke Shubha R
Department of Medical Genetics, SGPGIMS, Lucknow, India.
Department of Endocrinology, SGPGIMS, Lucknow, India.
Clin Genet. 2025 Jul 12. doi: 10.1111/cge.70003.
Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a heritable disorder characterized by bone fragility and marked genetic and phenotypic heterogeneity. This study explores the molecular and clinical spectrum of OI, with a focus on autosomal recessive (AR) forms, therapeutic outcomes, and bone mineral density (BMD) in carriers of AR OI-associated gene variants from the Indian population. A total of 78 clinically suspected OI patients were analyzed, yielding a high diagnostic rate of 92.3%. Exome sequencing was performed in all cases, with whole-genome sequencing in selected exome-negative cases. Autosomal dominant (AD) and AR OI accounted for 66% and 34% of cases, respectively. P3H1 (n = 11) was the most frequently implicated AR gene causing OI, followed by SERPINF1 (n = 5) and WNT1 (n = 4), with 79% of AR variants being novel. Phenotypic evaluation (n = 67) revealed fractures, short stature (87%), and bony deformities (84%) as predominant features. A rare homozygous COL1A1 variant was identified in one patient, while another patient harbored additional variants in AD OI genes, suggesting a potential digenic or modifier effect. Phenotypic severity followed the order from most to least severe: AR genes > COL1A2 (substitution and non-substitution) > COL1A1 (substitution > non-substitution). A self-designed, preliminary clinical severity scoring system ranked CRTAP followed by P3H1, as the AR genes associated with the most severe phenotypes. Therapeutic assessment showed a significant reduction in fracture incidence following zoledronate therapy only in the COL1A1 group, with no notable improvements in the COL1A2 or AR groups. Additionally, BMD evaluation in carrier parents of AR gene causing OI indicated a higher predisposition to low BMD among WNT1 gene carriers. However, these findings are preliminary and limited by small sample size. This study provides an extensive genotypic and phenotypic characterization of OI in the Indian population, with a focus on AR OI. It documents differential therapeutic responses among genetic subgroups and provides preliminary observations on BMD in carrier parents of AR OI-an aspect that has been less explored previously and suggest the need for tailored management strategies. The findings in this study also raise the possibility of genetic modifiers contributing to phenotypic variability, warranting further investigation.
成骨不全症(OI)是一种遗传性疾病,其特征为骨骼脆弱以及显著的遗传和表型异质性。本研究探讨了OI的分子和临床谱系,重点关注常染色体隐性(AR)形式、治疗结果以及来自印度人群的AR OI相关基因变异携带者的骨矿物质密度(BMD)。总共分析了78例临床疑似OI患者,诊断率高达92.3%。所有病例均进行了外显子组测序,部分外显子组阴性病例进行了全基因组测序。常染色体显性(AD)和AR OI分别占病例的66%和34%。P3H1(n = 11)是导致OI最常涉及的AR基因,其次是SERPINF1(n = 5)和WNT1(n = 4),79%的AR变异为新发现。表型评估(n = 67)显示骨折、身材矮小(87%)和骨骼畸形(84%)为主要特征。在一名患者中鉴定出一种罕见的纯合COL1A1变异,而另一名患者在AD OI基因中存在其他变异,提示可能存在双基因或修饰效应。表型严重程度从最严重到最不严重依次为:AR基因>COL1A2(替代和非替代)>COL1A1(替代>非替代)。一个自行设计的初步临床严重程度评分系统将CRTAP排在首位,其次是P3H1,作为与最严重表型相关的AR基因。治疗评估显示,仅在COL1A1组中,唑来膦酸治疗后骨折发生率显著降低,而COL1A2组或AR组无明显改善。此外,对导致OI的AR基因携带者父母的BMD评估表明,WNT1基因携带者中低BMD的易感性更高。然而,这些发现是初步的,且受样本量小的限制。本研究提供了印度人群中OI广泛的基因型和表型特征,重点关注AR OI。它记录了不同遗传亚组之间的不同治疗反应,并提供了关于AR OI携带者父母BMD的初步观察结果——这是一个此前较少探索的方面,并表明需要制定针对性的管理策略。本研究的发现还增加了遗传修饰因子导致表型变异的可能性,值得进一步研究。