Orton Linda, Palmer Richard, Ward Roslyn, Helmholz Petra, Strauss Geoffrey R, Davey Paul, Hennessey Neville W
School of Allied Health, Curtin University, Perth, WA 6845, Australia.
School of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Curtin University, Perth, WA 6845, Australia.
Diagnostics (Basel). 2025 Jul 16;15(14):1793. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics15141793.
: The Motor Speech Hierarchy (MSH) Probe Words (PWs) have yet to be validated as effective in discriminating between children with impaired and children with typically developing speech motor control. This preliminary study first examined the effectiveness of the mandibular control subtest of the MSH-PWs in distinguishing between typically developing (TD) and speech sound-disordered (SSD) children aged between 3 years 0 months and 3 years 6 months. Secondly, we compared automatically derived kinematic measures of jaw range and control with MSH-PW consensus scoring to assist in identifying deficits in mandibular control. : Forty-one children with TD speech and 13 with SSD produced the 10 words of the mandibular stage of the MSH-PWs. A consensus team of speech pathologists observed video recordings of the words to score motor speech control and phonetic accuracy, as detailed in the MSH-PW scoring criteria. Specific measures of jaw and lip movements during speech were also extracted to derive the objective measurements, with agreement between the perceptual and objective measures of jaw range and jaw control evaluated. : A significant difference between TD and SSD groups was found for jaw range ( = 0.006), voicing transitions ( = 0.004) and total mandibular scores ( = 0.015). SSD and TD group discrimination was significant (at alpha = 0.01) with a balanced classification accuracy of 0.79. Initial analysis indicates objective kinematic measures using facial tracking show good agreement with perceptual judgements of jaw range and jaw control. : The preliminary data indicate the MSH-PWs can discriminate TD speech from SSD at the level of mandibular control and can be used by clinicians to assess motor speech control. Further investigation of objective measures to support perceptual scoring is indicated.
运动言语层次结构(MSH)探测词(PW)在区分言语运动控制受损儿童和发育正常儿童方面的有效性尚未得到验证。这项初步研究首先考察了MSH-PW中下颌控制子测试在区分3岁0个月至3岁6个月发育正常(TD)儿童和语音障碍(SSD)儿童方面的有效性。其次,我们将自动得出的下颌活动范围和控制的运动学测量结果与MSH-PW共识评分进行比较,以帮助识别下颌控制方面的缺陷。:41名TD言语儿童和13名SSD儿童说出了MSH-PW下颌阶段的10个单词。一组言语病理学家组成的共识团队观察了这些单词的视频记录,以对运动言语控制和语音准确性进行评分,评分细节按照MSH-PW评分标准。还提取了言语过程中下颌和嘴唇运动的具体测量数据以得出客观测量结果,并评估了下颌活动范围和下颌控制的感知测量与客观测量之间的一致性。:发现TD组和SSD组在下颌活动范围(=0.006)、浊音过渡(=0.004)和下颌总分(=0.015)方面存在显著差异。SSD组和TD组的区分具有显著性(在α=0.01时),平衡分类准确率为0.79。初步分析表明,使用面部跟踪的客观运动学测量结果与下颌活动范围和下颌控制的感知判断具有良好的一致性。:初步数据表明,MSH-PW在下颌控制水平上能够区分TD言语和SSD言语,临床医生可使用该方法评估运动言语控制。建议进一步研究支持感知评分的客观测量方法。