Pizarra Adriel R
Department of Health Policy and Administration, College of Public Health, University of the Philippines Manila.
Acta Med Philipp. 2025 Jun 30;59(8):102-105. doi: 10.47895/amp.vi0.8104. eCollection 2025.
The global shortage of organs for transplantation is a critical public health issue, leading many countries to reassess their organ donation policies. In the Philippines, organ donation rates remain significantly low under the current opt-in system, where individuals must actively declare their consent to donate. This perspective examines the challenges and limitations of the opt-in system in the Philippines, considering cultural, operational, legal, and ethical factors. It also discusses the emergence and effectiveness of the opt-out system, where consent is presumed unless explicitly denied, and evaluates its potential applicability in the Philippine context. Drawing on international experiences and evidence, this paper argues that transitioning to an opt-out system-supported by appropriate legislation, infrastructure enhancements, and culturally sensitive public education-can significantly increase organ donation rates in the Philippines and better address the nation's organ shortage.
全球器官移植供体短缺是一个关键的公共卫生问题,促使许多国家重新评估其器官捐赠政策。在菲律宾,在当前的选择加入系统下,器官捐赠率仍然极低,在该系统中,个人必须主动声明同意捐赠。本文从文化、操作、法律和伦理因素等方面审视了菲律宾选择加入系统面临的挑战和局限性。它还讨论了选择退出系统(即除非明确拒绝否则即推定同意)的出现及有效性,并评估了其在菲律宾背景下的潜在适用性。借鉴国际经验和证据,本文认为,向由适当立法、基础设施改善及具有文化敏感性的公众教育所支持的选择退出系统过渡,能够显著提高菲律宾的器官捐赠率,并更好地解决该国的器官短缺问题。