Swain Satish, Ajayababu Anuj, Chowdhury Souradeep, Singh Gagandeep, Ray Animesh
Department of Infectious Disease, Christian Medical College, Vellore, India.
Department of Medicine and Microbiology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Mycoses. 2025 Aug;68(8):e70099. doi: 10.1111/myc.70099.
Triazoles are the cornerstone of therapy for various forms of aspergillosis. However, the emergence of triazole-resistant Aspergillus fumigatus (TRAF) isolates poses a growing global threat. Although Asia harbours the largest at-risk population, the burden of azole resistance in this region has yet to be systematically evaluated. This study aimed to systematically review available data on TRAF to estimate the overall burden of azole resistance.
We systematically searched four databases-PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, and Scopus-from inception to May 2025 using appropriate search strings. We included studies from Asia that reported data on azole-resistant Aspergillus isolates obtained from both environmental and clinical samples. The objective was to report the pooled proportion (frequency) of azole-resistant Aspergillus isolates from all studies reported from countries in Asia.
A total of 1284 studies were identified, of which 498 were screened for eligibility after removing duplicates. Following title and full-text screening, 401 studies were excluded. Ultimately, 97 unique studies were included, providing resistance data on 8,049 clinical and 6,949 environmental isolates of Aspergillus fumigatus. The pooled proportion of triazole-resistant A. fumigatus (TRAF) in clinical isolates (predominantly respiratory > ear > other sources) was 4% (95% CI: 3%-6%); whereas in environmental isolates, it was 14% (95% CI: 9%-20%). The proportion of TRAF varied by country of origin. Among clinical isolates, higher rates were observed in Türkiye (96/1273; 7.5%), India (59/979; 6.0%), Iran (39/522; 7.5%), and Japan (69/958; 7.2%). For environmental isolates, a higher proportion was reported in Iran (203/847; 24.0%), Thailand (27/161; 16.8%), and China (472/3671; 12.8%). Among all TRAF isolates, resistance to itraconazole was most common (86.3%), followed by posaconazole (66.5%) and voriconazole (65.4%). Notably, 53.5% of TRAF isolates were pan-triazole resistant. Mutation analysis for triazole resistance was performed in 408 clinical and 871 environmental isolates. The TR34/L98H mutation was the most frequently reported, detected in 34.5% of clinical and 38.6% of environmental isolates.
This study is the first to systematically review available data on azole resistance in Aspergillus fumigatus isolates obtained from environmental and clinical samples in Asia. The findings reveal a significant burden of azole-resistant isolates in clinical and environmental samples, underscoring their impact on disease management and treatment outcomes. Among the Asian population, triazole-resistant Aspergillus fumigatus (TRAF) can be seen in a small but significant proportion of patients with aspergillosis, most of which have been reported in pulmonary aspergillosis. This is likely linked to the significant burden in environmental isolates, as seen in these studies. In many such cases, multiple triazole drugs may be therapeutically ineffective, highlighting the need for a high degree of suspicion of TRAF in clinical practice. Future research should focus on investigating the underlying causes of resistance and developing potential interventions to address this pressing issue, which poses a serious threat to this vital class of antifungal agents.
三唑类药物是治疗各种曲霉病的基石。然而,耐三唑类烟曲霉(TRAF)菌株的出现对全球构成了日益严重的威胁。尽管亚洲拥有最大的高危人群,但该地区唑类耐药的负担尚未得到系统评估。本研究旨在系统回顾关于TRAF的现有数据,以估计唑类耐药的总体负担。
我们使用适当的检索词,从数据库创建至2025年5月,系统检索了四个数据库——PubMed、Web of Science、Embase和Scopus。我们纳入了来自亚洲的研究,这些研究报告了从环境和临床样本中获得的唑类耐药曲霉分离株的数据。目的是报告亚洲各国所有研究中唑类耐药曲霉分离株的合并比例(频率)。
共识别出1284项研究,去除重复项后,对其中498项进行了资格筛选。经过标题和全文筛选,排除了401项研究。最终,纳入了97项独特的研究,提供了8049株临床和6949株环境烟曲霉分离株的耐药数据。临床分离株(主要是呼吸道>耳部>其他来源)中耐三唑类烟曲霉(TRAF)的合并比例为4%(95%CI:3%-6%);而在环境分离株中,这一比例为14%(95%CI:9%-20%)。TRAF的比例因原产国而异。在临床分离株中,土耳其(96/1273;7.5%)、印度(59/979;6.0%)、伊朗(39/522;7.5%)和日本(69/958;7.2%)的发生率较高。对于环境分离株,伊朗(203/847;24.0%)、泰国(27/161;16.8%)和中国(472/3671;12.8%)报告的比例较高。在所有TRAF分离株中,对伊曲康唑的耐药最为常见(86.3%),其次是泊沙康唑(66.5%)和伏立康唑(65.4%)。值得注意的是,53.5%的TRAF分离株对三唑类药物全耐药。对408株临床和871株环境分离株进行了三唑类耐药的突变分析。TR34/L98H突变是最常报告的,在34.5%的临床分离株和38.6%的环境分离株中被检测到。
本研究首次系统回顾了从亚洲环境和临床样本中获得的烟曲霉分离株唑类耐药的现有数据。研究结果揭示了临床和环境样本中唑类耐药分离株的重大负担,突显了它们对疾病管理和治疗结果的影响。在亚洲人群中,一小部分但比例可观且患有曲霉病的患者体内可检测到耐三唑类烟曲霉(TRAF),其中大部分病例报告于肺曲霉病。正如这些研究所显示的,这可能与环境分离株中的重大负担有关。在许多此类病例中,多种三唑类药物可能治疗无效,这突出表明在临床实践中需要高度怀疑TRAF。未来的研究应侧重于调查耐药的根本原因,并制定潜在的干预措施来解决这一紧迫问题,该问题对这一重要类别的抗真菌药物构成了严重威胁。