Bergman J
Suicide Life Threat Behav. 1979 Winter;9(4):219-26. doi: 10.1111/j.1943-278x.1979.tb00440.x.
A review of the literature which examined the suicide rate among psychiatrists and other doctors was made. Particular attention was given to statistical and methodological problems. Common problems include small research sampling, inappropriate comparisons, lack of controls for age, sex, or other relevant factors, interpolating rates from a level per 10,000 to a level per 100,000, and inclusion of a number of unwarranted assumptions. The review did not find evidence that the suicide rate among psychiatrists is higher compared to the population as a whole; nor is there any evidence that the rates of any medical specialty are above average, controlling for the relevant variables. The materials reviewed included all published studies. In order adequately to assess the suicide rate among psychiatrists, a systematic and extensive study must be made, controlling for the relevant methodological variables.
对研究精神科医生和其他医生自杀率的文献进行了综述。特别关注了统计和方法学问题。常见问题包括研究样本量小、比较不当、缺乏对年龄、性别或其他相关因素的控制、将每10000人的比率推算至每100000人的比率,以及包含一些无根据的假设。该综述未发现证据表明精神科医生的自杀率高于总体人群;也没有证据表明在控制相关变量的情况下,任何医学专科的自杀率高于平均水平。所审查的资料包括所有已发表的研究。为了充分评估精神科医生的自杀率,必须进行系统而广泛的研究,并控制相关的方法学变量。