Tegeler J, Wöller W
Fortschr Neurol Psychiatr. 1983 Jun;51(6):203-26. doi: 10.1055/s-2007-1002227.
Studies on the treatments for neuroleptic-induced tardive dyskinesia published in the literature are reviewed. The great number of different treatments and the controversial results of most studies show that there is as yet no specific and safe treatment for tardive dyskinesia. Suggestions for well-designed treatment studies are given: Placebo-controlled double-blind design, larger patient populations, clear diagnostic and standard observing and rating conditions using different assessment methods and videotapes, withdrawal of neuroleptics and antiparkinsonian drugs to discover reversible tardive dyskinesia. If this procedure is not feasible, neuroleptics and other drugs should be maintained at a stable dose level. Longer term studies of some months are necessary to study the prolonged efficacy of different drugs. The effect of dopamine-antagonists such as neuroleptics and of dopamine-depleting agents such as reserpine and oxypertine is of limited duration. Dopamine-agonists such as L-Dopa, bromocriptine and amantadine help only few patients and may even aggravate the symptoms of tardive dyskinesia. In some double-blind studies cholinergic drugs such as lecithin and deanol have improved tardive dyskinesia, but further controlled studies are needed. Anticholinergic drugs such as antiparkinsonian agents should not be prescribed because they may aggravate tardive dyskinesia. Some patients respond to GABA-ergic agents such as baclofen, sodium valproate and the benzodiazepines, but further studies are needed before the value of GABA-ergic agents in the treatment of tardive dyskinesia can be properly assessed. After withdrawal of neuroleptics the average of remission rates within a year is 20%-30%. Elderly patients are more likely to have persistent dyskinesias. A progressive stepwise diminution of the neuroleptic dose and of the antiparkinsonian agents is recommended. When a patient's psychosis is exacerbated after withdrawal of the neuroleptics and tardive dyskinesia is also present, small doses of thioridazine, clozapine or tiapride can be administered. If this practice is not successful cholinergic or GABA-ergic agents may be useful. Because no currently available therapeutic agents satisfies the criteria of safety, marked effectiveness and prolonged efficacy in the treatment of tardive dyskinesia, prevention becomes more important. Prolonged use of a neuroleptic medication requires careful evaluation of indications and risks. The doses of neuroleptic drugs during the maintenance treatment of schizophrenia should be as small as possible.
本文回顾了文献中关于抗精神病药物所致迟发性运动障碍治疗方法的研究。大量不同的治疗方法以及大多数研究存在争议的结果表明,目前尚无针对迟发性运动障碍的特效且安全的治疗方法。文中给出了关于设计完善的治疗研究的建议:采用安慰剂对照双盲设计、纳入更多患者群体、在明确诊断及标准观察和评定条件下使用不同评估方法及录像带、停用抗精神病药物和抗帕金森病药物以发现可逆性迟发性运动障碍。若此方法不可行,则应将抗精神病药物和其他药物维持在稳定剂量水平。需要进行为期数月的长期研究以探讨不同药物的长期疗效。多巴胺拮抗剂如抗精神病药物以及多巴胺耗竭剂如利血平和奥昔哌汀的作用持续时间有限。多巴胺激动剂如左旋多巴、溴隐亭和金刚烷胺仅对少数患者有帮助,甚至可能加重迟发性运动障碍的症状。在一些双盲研究中,胆碱能药物如卵磷脂和地阿诺改善了迟发性运动障碍,但仍需进一步对照研究。不应开具抗胆碱能药物如抗帕金森病药物,因为它们可能加重迟发性运动障碍。一些患者对γ-氨基丁酸能药物如巴氯芬、丙戊酸钠和苯二氮䓬类药物有反应,但在能恰当评估γ-氨基丁酸能药物在治疗迟发性运动障碍中的价值之前,还需进一步研究。停用抗精神病药物后,一年内的平均缓解率为20% - 30%。老年患者更易出现持续性运动障碍。建议逐步递减抗精神病药物和抗帕金森病药物的剂量。当患者停用抗精神病药物后精神病症状加重且存在迟发性运动障碍时,可给予小剂量的硫利达嗪、氯氮平或替阿普明。若此方法无效,胆碱能或γ-氨基丁酸能药物可能会有用。由于目前尚无治疗药物能满足安全、显著有效及长期有效的标准来治疗迟发性运动障碍,预防就变得更为重要。长期使用抗精神病药物需要仔细评估适应证和风险。精神分裂症维持治疗期间抗精神病药物的剂量应尽可能小。