Bedikian A Y, Patt Y Z, Murphy W K, Umsawasadi T, Carr D T, Hersh E M, Bodey G P, Valdivieso M
Am J Clin Oncol. 1984 Oct;7(5):399-404. doi: 10.1097/00000421-198410000-00002.
One hundred five patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer were randomized to receive thymosin fraction V immunotherapy during remission induction chemotherapy with vindesine, doxorubicin, and cisplatin (VAP). Fifty-four patients received VAP alone. Fifty-one patients received VAP + thymosin. Both groups were comparable; most patients were male, with a good performance status and with the diagnosis of adenocarcinoma. Among 99 evaluable patients, response was seen in 24 (2 CRs, 22 PRs) of 53 (45%) patients treated with VAP and 10 (all PRs) of 46 (22%) patients treated with VAP + thymosin (p = 0.03). VAP-treated patients responded better than those treated with VAP + thymosin in each tumor category: adenocarcinoma, 50% of 36 patients versus 22% of 27 patients; squamous cell carcinoma, 29% of 14 patients versus 21% of 13 patients; undifferentiated carcinoma, 67% of three patients versus 17% of six patients. Median survival duration was 34 weeks versus 25 weeks in favor of the VAP-treated group (p = 0.14). Thymosin treatment resulted in decreased graft-vs.-host reaction (p = 0.01) and increased suppressor effect on normal mitogen response to Con-A (p = 0.17). The activity of VAP chemotherapy is comparable with the most effective multidrug regimens of the present time in patients with advanced non-small cell tumors. The addition of thymosin immunotherapy appeared to have a negative effect on the activity of VAP.
105例晚期非小细胞肺癌患者被随机分为两组,一组在使用长春地辛、阿霉素和顺铂(VAP)进行缓解诱导化疗期间接受胸腺素Ⅴ免疫治疗,另一组仅接受VAP治疗。54例患者仅接受VAP治疗,51例患者接受VAP+胸腺素治疗。两组具有可比性;大多数患者为男性,身体状况良好,诊断为腺癌。在99例可评估患者中,接受VAP治疗的53例患者中有24例(2例完全缓解,22例部分缓解)出现缓解,接受VAP+胸腺素治疗的46例患者中有10例(均为部分缓解)出现缓解(p=0.03)。在每个肿瘤类别中,接受VAP治疗的患者比接受VAP+胸腺素治疗的患者反应更好:腺癌,36例患者中的50%对比27例患者中的22%;鳞状细胞癌,14例患者中的29%对比13例患者中的21%;未分化癌,3例患者中的67%对比6例患者中的17%。中位生存时间为34周对比25周,VAP治疗组更具优势(p=0.14)。胸腺素治疗导致移植物抗宿主反应降低(p=0.01),对正常有丝分裂原Con-A反应的抑制作用增强(p=0.17)。VAP化疗在晚期非小细胞肿瘤患者中的活性与目前最有效的多药方案相当。添加胸腺素免疫治疗似乎对VAP的活性有负面影响。