Liew K H, Easton D, Horwich A, Barrett A, Peckham M J
Hematol Oncol. 1984 Jan-Mar;2(1):45-59. doi: 10.1002/hon.2900020106.
Of a total of 235 Stage I and II Hodgkin's disease patients treated between 1970 and 1979, 103 (43.8 per cent) had mediastinal involvement in 45 of whom the disease was bulky and in 58 non-bulky. This report concentrates on bulky disease patients of whom 45 per cent did not relapse after therapy and 71 per cent are alive. Patients with mediastinal disease were treated with radiotherapy (63), sequential chemo-radiotherapy (37) or chemotherapy alone (3). In the radiotherapy group the relapse rate for bulky disease was significantly higher (65 per cent) than for non-bulky disease (44 per cent) (P less than 0.05) although there was no significant difference in survival. Neither relapse rate nor survival differed significantly in bulky disease patients treated with radiotherapy compared with combined chemo-radiotherapy although there was a 20 per cent difference in relapse-free survival rate in favour of the combined treatment group at five years. Treatments were not allocated randomly and the chemo-radiotherapy group contained a disproportionate number of patients with adverse features (greater than 3 node areas involved, limited lung extension) compared with the irradiated group; 11/25 and 2/17 respectively. The number of lymph node areas involved appeared to influence the relapse rate in the radiotherapy group. There was no correlation between mediastinal mass size and number of node areas involved suggesting that these two features may be independent prognostic factors.
在1970年至1979年间接受治疗的235例I期和II期霍奇金病患者中,103例(43.8%)有纵隔受累,其中45例疾病为大包块型,58例为非大包块型。本报告主要关注大包块型疾病患者,其中45%的患者治疗后未复发,71%的患者存活。纵隔疾病患者接受了放射治疗(63例)、序贯放化疗(37例)或单纯化疗(3例)。在放射治疗组中,大包块型疾病的复发率(65%)显著高于非大包块型疾病(44%)(P<0.05),尽管生存率无显著差异。与联合放化疗相比,放射治疗的大包块型疾病患者的复发率和生存率均无显著差异,尽管联合治疗组在五年时的无复发生存率有20%的优势。治疗并非随机分配,与放疗组相比,放化疗组中具有不良特征(累及3个以上淋巴结区域、肺部受累范围有限)的患者比例过高;分别为11/25和2/17。受累淋巴结区域的数量似乎影响放射治疗组的复发率。纵隔肿块大小与受累淋巴结区域数量之间无相关性,提示这两个特征可能是独立的预后因素。