Wesselius L J, Witztum K F, Taylor A T, Hartman M T, Moser K M
Am Rev Respir Dis. 1983 Dec;128(6):1084-9. doi: 10.1164/arrd.1983.128.6.1084.
The pulmonary uptake of 87Ga citrate has been proposed as an index that assists clinical decision-making in patients with certain interstitial lung diseases. Such use, however, requires definition of the range of normal values, the range of values in patients with various interstitial diseases, and interobserver and intraobserver variability. We studied 9 normal subjects and 15 patients with interstitial lung diseases. The 87Ga indexes were determined by visual analysis and by a computer-assisted method. We found that the variation among experienced observers in visual index values was substantial in both normal subjects and patients, and that the computer-assisted indexes were less variable. These data suggest that if this approach is to be used in clinical decision-making: (1) the variability of visual indexes, and of normal values, should be recognized; (2) consideration should be given to a less subjective, computer-assisted method of index calculation; (3) each institution should establish standardized methodology and consider determination of its range of variability and normal index values.
有人提出,87Ga柠檬酸盐的肺部摄取可作为一项指标,辅助某些间质性肺疾病患者的临床决策。然而,这种应用需要明确正常数值范围、各种间质性疾病患者的数值范围,以及观察者间和观察者内的变异性。我们研究了9名正常受试者和15名间质性肺疾病患者。通过视觉分析和计算机辅助方法确定87Ga指标。我们发现,无论是正常受试者还是患者,经验丰富的观察者之间视觉指标值的差异都很大,而计算机辅助指标的变异性较小。这些数据表明,如果要将这种方法用于临床决策:(1)应认识到视觉指标及正常数值的变异性;(2)应考虑采用主观性较小的计算机辅助指标计算方法;(3)每个机构都应建立标准化方法,并考虑确定其变异性范围和正常指标值。