Escreet B C, Cowie R L
S Afr Med J. 1983 May 28;63(22):850-4.
Diagnostic criteria for pulmonary tuberculosis are presented in the form of a weighted diagnostic protocol. These criteria were evolved to standardize the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis for a prospective study of the disease and its treatment, and were first tested in the evaluation of 469 referred patients, of whom 300 were found to have tuberculosis. The criteria have subsequently been validated clinically and statistically through their application to 1679 patients with radiological abnormalities suggestive of tuberculous disease, of whom 1154 were proved to have pulmonary tuberculosis. Application of these criteria whenever pulmonary tuberculosis is suspected has removed the dilemma often faced by clinicians when presented with a suggestive chest radiograph, a single sputum smear positive for acid-fast bacilli resembling Mycobacterium tuberculosis, or a strongly positive tuberculin test. We believe that these criteria put each of these separate findings into perspective. They allow the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis to be made with confidence and prevent the erroneous diagnosis of non-tuberculous disease. Their use should alleviate the tendency towards an overdiagnosis of active pulmonary tuberculous disease, and thereby the waste of therapeutic and social resources.
肺结核的诊断标准以加权诊断方案的形式呈现。这些标准是为了使肺结核诊断标准化,以便对该疾病及其治疗进行前瞻性研究而制定的,并且首次在对469例转诊患者的评估中进行了测试,其中300例被发现患有肺结核。这些标准随后通过应用于1679例有结核疾病影像学异常的患者而在临床和统计学上得到验证,其中1154例被证实患有肺结核。每当怀疑有肺结核时应用这些标准,消除了临床医生面对提示性胸部X光片、痰涂片抗酸杆菌阳性(类似结核分枝杆菌)或结核菌素试验强阳性时常常面临的困境。我们认为,这些标准使这些单独的发现都能得到正确看待。它们使肺结核的诊断能够自信地做出,并防止对非结核疾病的错误诊断。使用这些标准应能缓解对活动性肺结核疾病过度诊断的趋势,从而避免治疗和社会资源的浪费。