Dickinson J C, Gehlbach S H
J Fam Pract. 1978 Sep;7(3):557-62.
Records of 87 hypertensive patients in a group family practice were reviewed to assess the validity of the process audit in determining medical care quality. Although a significant reduction in mean diastolic blood pressures was found at two follow-up intervals, physician performance scores showed no significant correlation with this outcome. Nor could an association between medical process and outcome be demonstrated when control of blood pressure to less than 95 mmHg was used as an outcome measure. The reliability between two chart auditors was poor, with complete agreement being achieved in only 29 percent of cases. Accurate quality assessment will require more practical methods of review which relate directly to patient outcomes.
回顾了一组家庭医疗实践中87名高血压患者的记录,以评估过程审核在确定医疗质量方面的有效性。尽管在两个随访间隔中发现平均舒张压有显著降低,但医生的绩效评分与这一结果并无显著相关性。当将血压控制在95 mmHg以下作为结果指标时,也无法证明医疗过程与结果之间存在关联。两位病历审核员之间的可靠性较差,只有29%的病例达成了完全一致。准确的质量评估将需要更直接与患者结果相关的实用审核方法。