Chate R A
Am J Orthod. 1980 May;77(5):547-67. doi: 10.1016/0002-9416(80)90133-5.
The literature on the physics, the radiation hazard, and the current medicodental applications of xeroradiography is reviewed. A study is presented on estimating the effect of a xeroradiographic technique on the degree of inter- and intraobserver error in cephalometric landmark identification, as compared to a radiographic technique. This study involved identification by four observers of sixteen cephalometric landmarks on twelve xeroradiographs and twelve radiographs, on two separate occasions. The conclusions are that neither technique provided a significant reduction in interobserver differences. However, for eight of the thirty-two variables (nasion's Y axis, portion's X and Y axes, basion's X axis, Bolton point's X axis, anterior nasal spine's X axis, menton's Y axis, and the tip of the nose's X axis), as opposed to two (basion's Y axis and gonion's Y axis), xeroradiography produced a significant reduction in intraobserver error in comparison to radiography.
本文综述了关于干板X线摄影的物理学、辐射危害以及当前在医学牙科领域应用的文献。与传统X线摄影技术相比,本研究对干板X线摄影技术对头影测量标志点识别过程中观察者间和观察者内误差程度的影响进行了评估。本研究要求四位观察者在两个不同的时间,分别在十二张干板X线片和十二张传统X线片上识别十六个头影测量标志点。结果表明,两种技术均未显著减少观察者间的差异。然而,在三十二个变量中的八个变量(鼻根点的Y轴、颏部的X轴和Y轴、颅底点的X轴、Bolton点的X轴、前鼻棘的X轴、颏下点的Y轴以及鼻尖的X轴)方面,与两个变量(颅底点的Y轴和下颌角点的Y轴)不同,与传统X线摄影相比,干板X线摄影显著减少了观察者内误差。