Reckling F W
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1982 Jul;64(6):857-63.
Forty-nine Monteggia and forty-seven Galeazzi lesions were treated over a twenty-five-year period. I used Bado's criteria to evaluate the results in the Monteggia lesions. In all of the children in the series either closed or open reduction yielded good results, while the results of treatment of the Monteggia fractures in the adults in the study varied. The best results were obtained in Type-I lesions treated by open anatomical reduction, internal stabilization of the ulnar fracture, and closed reduction of the radial head. Factors leading to poor results in Type-I lesions were failure to obtain anatomical reduction of the ulna, heterotopic ossification including synostosis of the proximal parts of the radius and ulna, and persistence or recurrence of dislocation of the radial head. In patients in whom the radial head could not be reduced by closed methods, the radial head was buttonholed through the joint capsule and the annular ligament was displaced but not ruptured. I have not found that reconstruction of the annular ligament is necessary in the treatment of acute Monteggia fractures. In the Type-II, III, and IV lesions in this series, fair results were the rule. The results of closed reduction of the classic Galeazzi fractures in the adults in this series were not good, due to malunion of the radius and persistent derangement of the distal radio-ulnar joint. The seventeen patients who were treated with accurate reduction and internal fixation of the fractured radius and immobilization of the forearm in full supination for six to eight weeks obtained good results.
在25年的时间里,共治疗了49例孟氏骨折和47例盖氏骨折。我采用巴多的标准来评估孟氏骨折的治疗结果。在该系列所有儿童患者中,无论是闭合复位还是切开复位都取得了良好的效果,而该研究中成年患者孟氏骨折的治疗结果则各不相同。I型损伤采用切开解剖复位、尺骨骨折内固定及桡骨头闭合复位治疗效果最佳。导致I型损伤治疗效果不佳的因素包括未能实现尺骨的解剖复位、异位骨化(包括桡骨和尺骨近端的骨性连接)以及桡骨头脱位的持续或复发。对于闭合复位无法使桡骨头复位的患者,通过关节囊将桡骨头穿出,环状韧带移位但未断裂。我发现在治疗急性孟氏骨折时,重建环状韧带并无必要。在该系列的II型、III型和IV型损伤中,一般结果较为常见。该系列成年患者中经典盖氏骨折闭合复位的效果不佳,原因是桡骨畸形愈合以及下尺桡关节持续紊乱。17例接受桡骨骨折精确复位及内固定并将前臂完全旋后固定6至8周的患者取得了良好的效果。