Mata A G, Rosengart R M
Pediatrics. 1980 Jul;66(1):68-71.
A total of 17 radiographs from seven babies with clinical evidence of necrotizing enterocolitis were examined by six pediatric radiologist and four neonatologists from the Southern California area. The participants were asked to interpret each radiograph as to the presence or absence of necrotizing enterocolitis and to indicate whether pneumoperitoneum was present. A substantial degree of interobserver variability was observed, with only one of the 17 films yielding universal agreement. We propose that this interobserver variability in interpreting abdominal films of neonates with clinically suspected necrotizing enterocolitis may in fact contribute to the reported difference in incidence of this disease among centers.
来自南加州地区的六位儿科放射科医生和四位新生儿科医生对七名有坏死性小肠结肠炎临床证据的婴儿的17张X光片进行了检查。要求参与者解读每张X光片,判断是否存在坏死性小肠结肠炎,并指出是否存在气腹。观察到观察者之间存在很大程度的差异,17张片子中只有一张得到了一致认可。我们认为,在解读临床怀疑患有坏死性小肠结肠炎的新生儿腹部X光片时,观察者之间的这种差异实际上可能导致了各中心报道的该疾病发病率的差异。