Flatow E L, Duralde X A, Nicholson G P, Pollock R G, Bigliani L U
Shoulder Service, New York Orthopaedic Hospital, Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center, New York, NY.
J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 1995 Jan-Feb;4(1 Pt 1):41-50. doi: 10.1016/s1058-2746(10)80007-2.
Forty-one patients (41 shoulders) with acromioclavicular joint disease refractory to conservative treatment underwent arthroscopic distal clavicle resection. Thirty-one men and 10 women with an average age of 32 years were studied. The dominant extremity was involved in 68% of the patients. At an average follow-up period of 31 months (range 24 to 49 months), 18 excellent, 16 good, and seven poor results were found. Twenty-seven (93%) of 29 shoulders with acromioclavicular arthritis or osteolysis of the distal clavicle went on to have satisfactory results compared with only seven (58%) of 12 shoulders with previous grade II acromioclavicular separations or acromioclavicular hypermobility. Total amount of bone removal did not correlate with success, if the resection was even. Five reoperations were done; one uneven resection was revised with arthroscopy, and four shoulders underwent acromioclavicular stabilization procedures. The high failure rate in patients with even subtle acromioclavicular instability (42%) suggests that in these cases formal stabilization with ligament reconstruction should be considered in addition to resection of the distal clavicle.
41例(41个肩关节)经保守治疗无效的肩锁关节疾病患者接受了关节镜下远端锁骨切除术。研究对象包括31名男性和10名女性,平均年龄32岁。68%的患者患侧为优势肢体。平均随访31个月(范围24至49个月),结果为18例优、16例良、7例差。29例肩锁关节炎或远端锁骨骨质溶解的肩关节中有27例(93%)取得了满意的结果,而12例既往有Ⅱ级肩锁关节分离或肩锁关节活动过度的肩关节中只有7例(58%)取得了满意的结果。如果切除均匀,骨切除总量与手术成功与否无关。进行了5次再次手术;1例切除不均匀的患者通过关节镜进行了翻修,4个肩关节接受了肩锁关节稳定手术。即使是轻微肩锁关节不稳定的患者,其高失败率(42%)表明,在这些病例中,除了切除远端锁骨外,还应考虑采用韧带重建进行正式的稳定手术。