Lavigne P, Loriot de Rouvray T H
Clinique Saint Joseph, Alençon.
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 1994;80(3):188-95.
The Transgluteal approach (TGa) to the hip, proposed by BAUER, and often used for total arthroplasties, could be responsible, according to some authors for bad clinical results, due to injury of the nervus gluteus superius (NGS). The aim of this study was to verify the nerve's anatomical condition and evaluate the risks of injury during TGa.
Thirty three dissections of fresh corpses in the lateral position (preceded by a TGa) permitted the estimation of the risk and the measurement of the distances between the nerve and the trochanter major (TM). The NGS was sought in the area of the foramen ischiaticum at the proximal side of the piriformis muscle after cutting the vessels and the fat. It was possible to follow it's branches to the end, but we had to lift the m. gluteus medius (mGM), or to cut it transversally.
Many anatomical variations were found concerning the point of the nerve's division into 2 branches, nearer or farther from the foramen ischiaticum. The upper branch followed the proximal side of the gluteus minimus (GMin) then innervated the GM and the m. tensor fasciae latae (TFL). the lower branch showed a variable distribution of the strings to the three muscles (GM, GMin and TFL). The TFL's branch ended at upper side of the TM. A safe area, over the TM, without any nerve branches could be determined 7 cm above and behind the TM, 5 cm above it's posterior angle and 3 cm above it's anterior angle. During anterior TGa we noted that the coxofemoral dislocation could tear the GM's proximal fibers and threatened the "inter" or intramuscular nerve filaments. The acetabular exposition by retractors, could compress the more frontal branches. On the contrary using the posterior TGa, neither the dislocation nor the exposition seemed to threaten the nerve, which was farther away and more posterior.
In this study we confirmed the existence of numerous anatomical variations of the NGS and classified them into 4 categories which include those already described in previous publications, of which the first category seems to be the most common. Our distances measured from the nerve to the TM are similar to those previously published, but our safe area is more restrictive than that proposed by Jacobs and Buxton. Respecting the limits of this area reduces the risk of nerve injuries. During the anterior TGa, the nerve is nearer to the TM and more exposed. The muscular mass innervated is large and the functional consequences of frontal injury must not be neglected. During acetabular exposition, the retractors should exert moderate muscular pressure, to avoid crushing them. The respect of the GMin, ensures adequate protection for the nerves situated between the muscles. To avoid muscular tearing during the anterior dislocation it is better to cut the collum femoris in place. The posterior approach seemed to be less dangerous for the nerves and muscles which are farther away.
Strictly remaining within the limits of the safe area and carefully separating the muscles, should allow to decrease the risk of NGS injuries during TGa which seems to be more important in the anterior than in the posterior approaches.
由鲍尔提出的经臀肌入路(TGa)用于髋关节手术,常用于全关节置换术。一些作者认为,由于臀上神经(NGS)损伤,该入路可能导致不良临床结果。本研究旨在验证该神经的解剖状况,并评估经臀肌入路过程中神经损伤的风险。
对33具新鲜尸体进行侧卧位解剖(先采用经臀肌入路),以评估风险,并测量神经与大转子(TM)之间的距离。在切断血管和脂肪后,在梨状肌近端的坐骨孔区域寻找臀上神经。可以追踪其分支直至末端,但必须抬起臀中肌(mGM),或者横向切断它。
发现神经分为两支的位置存在许多解剖变异,离坐骨孔较近或较远。上支沿臀小肌(GMin)近端走行,然后支配臀中肌和阔筋膜张肌(TFL)。下支向三块肌肉(臀中肌、臀小肌和阔筋膜张肌)发出的肌支分布各异。阔筋膜张肌的分支在大转子上方终止。在大转子上方、后方7厘米处,大转子后角上方5厘米处以及大转子前角上方3厘米处,可以确定一个没有任何神经分支的安全区域。在前侧经臀肌入路过程中,我们注意到髋关节脱位可能会撕裂臀中肌的近端纤维,并威胁到“肌间”或肌内神经纤维。使用牵开器暴露髋臼时,可能会压迫更靠前的分支。相反,采用后侧经臀肌入路时,脱位和暴露似乎都不会威胁到神经,因为神经位置更远且更靠后。
在本研究中,我们证实了臀上神经存在众多解剖变异,并将其分为4类,其中包括先前出版物中已描述的变异,第一类似乎最为常见。我们测量的神经到转子间嵴的距离与先前发表的结果相似,但我们确定的安全区域比雅各布斯和巴克斯顿提出的更具局限性。遵守该区域的界限可降低神经损伤的风险。在前侧经臀肌入路时,神经更靠近转子间嵴且更易暴露。所支配的肌肉量较大,前方损伤的功能后果不容忽视。在暴露髋臼时,牵开器应施加适度的肌肉压力,以避免压迫神经。保护臀小肌可确保对位于肌肉之间的神经提供充分保护。为避免前脱位时肌肉撕裂,最好在原位切断股骨颈。后侧入路对距离较远的神经和肌肉似乎危险性较小。
严格保持在安全区域的界限内并小心分离肌肉,应可降低经臀肌入路过程中臀上神经损伤的风险,在前侧入路中这种风险似乎比后侧入路更为重要。