Effect of out-of-hospital albuterol inhalation treatments on patient comfort and morbidity.

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To determine the effect of the institution of out-of-hospital albuterol treatments for acute asthma on out-of-hospital time intervals emergency department (ED) morbidity.

DESIGN

Retrospective chart and ambulance run report review.

PARTICIPANTS

All patients who presented with a diagnosis of asthma on the ED record and ambulance run report during 1988 and 1990.

RESULTS

Ninety patients treated prior to the routine use of nebulized albuterol (in 1988) and 86 patients treated during the period after the institution of nebulized albuterol (in 1990) were compared. Age, sex, scene and travel times, vital signs, peak expiratory flow rates, length of ED stay, hospitalizations, ED treatment, and mortality were recorded for each patient. Changes over time were determined using a cohort of asthma patients in each year as controls. Severity was recorded as low (less than 3) or high (3 or more) on a modified Fischl index for asthma. Groups were compared by F test, chi 2, or t test with P < .05 considered significant. Because there were differences for admission rates, first-hospital peak expiratory flow rates, and aminophylline use in control groups, the experimental groups could not be compared. No significant difference in travel interval, steroid use, albuterol treatments, or length of ED stay was determined in either the experimental or control group. Scene time (9.7 minutes versus 12.1 minutes) was significantly shorter in 1988 than in 1990 (difference, 2.4 minutes; 95% confidence interval, 0.2 to 4.6; P < .01). The percentage of patients with high initial severity of disease (85% versus 66%; P < .001) and the percentage of patients with first posttreatment peak expiratory flow rates of less than 120 L/min (77% versus 58%; P < .001) were significantly higher in 1988 than in 1990. There was no significant difference in scene time, severity scores, or first posttreatment peak expiratory flow rates in control groups.

CONCLUSION

The institution of out-of-hospital use of nebulized albuterol increased scene time and increased first posttreatment peak expiratory flow rates significantly. There was a significant decrease in initial patient severity as measured on the modified Fischl index, although the validity of this index has not been established. It did not affect travel interval, length of stay in the ED, or medication use after ED presentation.