Reaby L L, Hort L K, Vandervord J
Health Care Women Int. 1994 Sep-Oct;15(5):361-75. doi: 10.1080/07399339409516129.
The perceptions of three groups of women regarding their body image, self-concept, total self-image, and self-esteem were compared. The groups included 64 women who had mastectomies and wore external breast prostheses, 31 women who had mastectomies and underwent breast reconstruction, and a control group of 78 women who had not experienced mastectomy. The body image, total self-image, and self-esteem mean scores indicated that the prosthesis and reconstruction groups had more positive feelings regarding their bodies than did the control group. There were no significant differences in self-concept among the three groups. These findings challenge a common assumption that mastectomy automatically results in psychiatric morbidity caused by an altered body image and suggest that health professionals should not make assumptions about how a woman will psychologically respond to mastectomy.
比较了三组女性对其身体形象、自我概念、整体自我形象和自尊的认知。这三组女性分别为:64名接受了乳房切除术并佩戴外部乳房假体的女性;31名接受了乳房切除术并进行了乳房重建的女性;以及一个由78名未经历乳房切除术的女性组成的对照组。身体形象、整体自我形象和自尊的平均得分表明,佩戴假体组和乳房重建组对自己身体的感受比对照组更为积极。三组之间在自我概念方面没有显著差异。这些发现挑战了一个普遍的假设,即乳房切除术会自动导致因身体形象改变而引发的精神疾病,并表明健康专业人员不应臆断女性对乳房切除术的心理反应。