Vogl C, Atchley W R, Xu S
Department of Genetics, North Carolina State University, Raleigh 27695-7614.
J Craniofac Genet Dev Biol. 1994 Apr-Jun;14(2):97-110.
We have analyzed the postnatal ontogeny of the mandible of two inbred strains of mice (C3HeB and C57/BL) with conventional statistical analysis of area traits and with Euclidian Distance Matrix Analysis (EDMA). The relative contribution of the distal tooth-bearing part of the mandible to the area of the whole mandible decreases over time. The most prominent differences in shape between mice of 10 days and 25 days postnatal age are found in the lower posterior part of the mandible. Between angular and condylar process intramembranous ossification proceeds at a high rate and gradually fills the space between these two processes. The position of the proximal end of the molar tooth-row is relocated ventrally during this period. Morphological differences between C3H and C57 are most pronounced at 15 days postnatal age. Regions that discriminate best between the two strains change during development. While differences in the coronoid process separate the two groups clearly at 10 and 25 days postnatal age, no significant differences in the coronoid process are found at 20 days postnatal age. Similarly, masseter area shows significant differences at 15 and 25 days postnatal age, while C57 and C3H mice are equivalent for this trait at the other times. The same qualitative results are obtained by Euclidian Distance Matrix Analysis (EDMA): regions of major differences between strains are not consistent among ages. These results suggest that the ontogeny of morphological differences between closely related taxa is quite an erratic process; development of morphometric differences does not proceed smoothly and continuously. This unpredictable pattern of development of morphometric differences is expected if development of the mandible is tightly integrated by epigenetic and regulatory processes.
我们采用面积性状的传统统计分析方法和欧几里得距离矩阵分析(EDMA),对两种近交系小鼠(C3HeB和C57/BL)下颌骨的出生后个体发育进行了分析。下颌骨远端有牙部分对整个下颌骨面积的相对贡献随时间而降低。出生后10天和25天的小鼠在下颌骨下部后部的形状差异最为显著。在角突和髁突之间,膜内成骨以高速进行,并逐渐填充这两个突起之间的间隙。在此期间,磨牙列近端的位置向腹侧重新定位。C3H和C57之间的形态差异在出生后15天最为明显。在发育过程中,能最佳区分这两个品系的区域会发生变化。虽然在出生后10天和25天,冠突的差异能清楚地将两组分开,但在出生后20天,冠突没有显著差异。同样,咬肌面积在出生后15天和25天显示出显著差异,而在其他时间,C57和C3H小鼠在这一特征上相当。通过欧几里得距离矩阵分析(EDMA)也获得了相同的定性结果:品系之间主要差异的区域在不同年龄并不一致。这些结果表明,近缘分类群之间形态差异的个体发育是一个相当不稳定的过程;形态测量差异的发展并非平稳连续地进行。如果下颌骨的发育通过表观遗传和调控过程紧密整合,那么形态测量差异的这种不可预测的发展模式是可以预期的。