Roman S A, McGanney M L
Sophie Davis School of Biomedical Education, City University of New York Medical School, New York 10031.
Acad Med. 1994 Mar;69(3):224-30. doi: 10.1097/00001888-199403000-00018.
Since 1973 the Sophie Davis School of Biomedical Education, City University of New York Medical School, has integrated baccalaureate education with preclinical medical education; its graduates earn BS degrees in five years and are then eligible for entry into the traditional third year of medical school at one of seven participating medical schools in New York State. The school has a twofold mission: (1) to expand access to medical careers among inner-city youths, particularly among underrepresented minorities, and (2) to encourage the pursuit of primary care specialties among its graduates.
To assess the extent to which the two goals of the school have been met, the authors collected and analyzed information on the 1,402 students who entered Sophie Davis between 1973 and 1992, especially the 1,068 students from the 15 classes that entered the school from 1973-74 through 1987-88. In particular, the analysis focused on data on academic achievement and on choice of practice specialty. Where possible, state and national data were used for comparison.
The results suggest that the school has achieved varying degrees of success: (1) The program has expanded access to medical careers among underrepresented-minority students at success rates well above national averages for college freshmen entering traditional premedical curricula. (2) Graduates have chosen primary care specialties at a somewhat higher rate than the national average, despite the school's lack of official involvement with students once they began clinical training in medical school.
The aggregate data show that the school has achieved success in expanding access to medical careers for inner-city youth (especially among underrepresented minorities) and has been at least partially successful in nurturing primary care physicians. The latter goal may be realized more fully if the school becomes more involved in the clinical education of its graduates.
自1973年以来,纽约城市大学医学院的索菲·戴维斯生物医学教育学院将学士学位教育与临床前医学教育相结合;其毕业生在五年内获得理学学士学位,随后有资格进入纽约州七所参与合作的医学院之一的传统医学三年级学习。该学院有双重使命:(1)扩大城市内青年,特别是代表性不足的少数族裔群体获得医疗职业的机会;(2)鼓励其毕业生从事初级保健专业。
为评估该学院的两个目标实现的程度,作者收集并分析了1973年至1992年进入索菲·戴维斯学院的1402名学生的信息,特别是1973 - 74年至1987 - 88年入学的15个班级的1068名学生的信息。具体而言,分析集中在学业成绩数据和实践专业选择上。在可能的情况下,使用州和国家数据进行比较。
结果表明该学院取得了不同程度的成功:(1)该项目扩大了代表性不足的少数族裔学生获得医疗职业的机会,成功率远高于进入传统医学预科课程的大学新生的全国平均水平。(2)尽管该学院在学生开始医学院临床培训后未正式参与其中,但毕业生选择初级保健专业的比例略高于全国平均水平。
总体数据表明,该学院在扩大城市内青年(特别是代表性不足的少数族裔)获得医疗职业的机会方面取得了成功,并且在培养初级保健医生方面至少部分取得了成功。如果该学院更多地参与其毕业生的临床教育,后一个目标可能会更充分地实现。