Pechadre J C, Beudin P, Trolese J F, Gabet J Y, Eschalier A
Service d'Electroencéphalographie Explorations Fonctionnelles du Système Nerveux, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire, Clermont Ferrand, France.
J Int Med Res. 1993 Sep-Oct;21(5):234-42. doi: 10.1177/030006059302100502.
A double-blind, randomized controlled trial using an electroencephalograph computerized analysis and cartography was carried out to investigate the spectral modifications induced by diazepam and hydroxyzine. Without monitoring response to stimulation, the spectra found for diazepam and for hydroxyzine were qualitatively very similar, showing increase of the slow waves, reduction of the alpha rhythm and accentuation of the beta 1 rhythms. These traces suggested strongly that both drugs had produced a sedative, anti-anxiety effect. The intensity of the effect produced by 50 mg of hydroxyzine appeared to be less than that produced by 10 mg diazepam. After monitoring response to stimulation, the spectra were modified and the reactivity of the two drugs differed with regard to the slow delta, theta and alpha 1 frequency bands. It was possible to distinguish between the sedative and anti-anxiety effects of both diazepam and hydroxyzine. Even if the two drugs had some similar effects, the mode of action in the central nervous system was certainly different, as can be seen from the characteristics of distribution of the slow waves, their reactivity and, with regard to frequency, the fluctuation of the dominant frequency of rapid rhythms.
开展了一项双盲随机对照试验,使用脑电图计算机分析和制图技术来研究地西泮和羟嗪引起的频谱变化。在未监测刺激反应的情况下,地西泮和羟嗪的频谱在质量上非常相似,表现为慢波增加、α节律减少和β1节律增强。这些记录强烈表明两种药物都产生了镇静、抗焦虑作用。50毫克羟嗪产生的效果强度似乎小于10毫克地西泮产生的效果强度。在监测刺激反应后,频谱发生了改变,两种药物在慢δ、θ和α1频段的反应性有所不同。可以区分地西泮和羟嗪的镇静和抗焦虑作用。即使两种药物有一些相似的效果,但从慢波分布特征、它们的反应性以及快速节律的主导频率波动来看,它们在中枢神经系统的作用方式肯定不同。