Gifford R R, Neuymer M M, Yang H C, Escobar F S, Thiele B L
Department of Surgery, Section of Transplantation, University Hospital, Pennsylvania State University College of Medicine, Hershey 17033.
Clin Transplant. 1994 Feb;8(1):40-4.
Duplex ultrasonography has met with variable accuracy in identifying acute renal allograft rejection. These published studies have focused on using mathematical indices. We have applied duplex ultrasonography differently by insonating the site of rejection, i.e. renal cortex, to identify by subjective analysis the changes of the velocity spectral patterns. This subjective analysis method was compared to the mathematical indices of diastolic/systolic ratio and pulsatility index in 126 episodes of clinical acute renal allograft rejection which all had biopsy correlation. This present study represents the largest published experience with duplex ultrasonography and renal transplant rejection. Subjective analysis of velocity spectral patterns (SUBJ) resulted in sensitivity of 87%, specificity of 94% and overall accuracy of 88%. This technique was statistically better than the diastolic/systolic ratio (DSR) sensitivity of 40%, specificity of 72% and overall accuracy of 49%, or the pulsatility index (PI) sensitivity of 47%, specificity of 75% and overall accuracy of 55%. The superior results of the subjective analysis technique of duplex ultrasonography to identify acute renal allograft rejection suggests that this diagnostic approach has sufficient accuracy to avoid invasive allograft biopsies.
在识别急性肾移植排斥反应方面,双功超声检查的准确性存在差异。这些已发表的研究主要集中在使用数学指标上。我们采用了不同的双功超声检查方法,通过对排斥反应部位(即肾皮质)进行超声检查,以主观分析的方式识别速度频谱模式的变化。在126例均有活检相关性的临床急性肾移植排斥反应病例中,将这种主观分析方法与舒张期/收缩期比值和搏动指数的数学指标进行了比较。本研究是已发表的关于双功超声检查与肾移植排斥反应的最大规模经验。对速度频谱模式的主观分析(SUBJ)的敏感性为87%,特异性为94%,总体准确率为88%。该技术在统计学上优于舒张期/收缩期比值(DSR),其敏感性为40%,特异性为72%,总体准确率为49%;也优于搏动指数(PI),其敏感性为47%,特异性为75%,总体准确率为55%。双功超声检查主观分析技术在识别急性肾移植排斥反应方面的优异结果表明,这种诊断方法具有足够的准确性,可避免进行侵入性的移植肾活检。