Helfet D L, Howey T, Dipasquale T, Sanders R, Zinar D, Brooker A
Hospital for Special Surgery, Orthopaedic Trauma Service, New York, New York.
Orthop Rev. 1994 Feb;Suppl:9-17.
A multicenter, prospective study was conducted to assess the efficacy of an unreamed, double-locked tibial nail for the acute management of open and/or unstable tibial fractures. Seventy-seven acute unstable and/or open tibial fractures in 74 patients were treated from December 1986 to February 1989. Forty fractures were closed and 37 were open; 25% occurred in polytraumatized patients and 39% of the patients had additional fractures. All closed tibial fractures healed at an average of 14.2 weeks; 94.6% of the open tibial fractures healed at an average of 20.1 weeks. There were no infections in the closed tibial fracture group. There were 4 infections among the 37 patients (11%) in the open tibial fracture group, 2 superficial and 2 deep. There were 7 problems intraoperatively (8.4%) with fin deployment: 2 fins bent during nail insertion, 4 fins penetrated the cortex, while 1 set of fins only partially deployed. Difficulty was encountered with proximal screw insertion in one third of the cases. Considering the high energy of these injuries, the treatment of open and/or unstable tibial fractures with an unreamed, double-locked tibial nail can offer the surgeon a high rate of union (97%) with minimal complications. The low infection rate found in this series indicates that this nail may be of particular benefit in the treatment of closed and select open tibial fractures.
一项多中心前瞻性研究旨在评估非扩髓双锁定胫骨髓内钉治疗开放性和/或不稳定型胫骨骨折的急性处理效果。1986年12月至1989年2月,对74例患者的77处急性不稳定型和/或开放性胫骨骨折进行了治疗。其中40处为闭合性骨折,37处为开放性骨折;25%发生于多发伤患者,39%的患者伴有其他骨折。所有闭合性胫骨骨折平均在14.2周愈合;94.6%的开放性胫骨骨折平均在20.1周愈合。闭合性胫骨骨折组无感染发生。开放性胫骨骨折组37例患者中有4例发生感染(11%),2例表浅感染,2例深部感染。术中出现7个与鳍片相关的问题(8.4%):2个鳍片在插入髓内钉时弯曲,4个鳍片穿透皮质,1组鳍片仅部分展开。三分之一的病例在近端螺钉插入时遇到困难。考虑到这些损伤的高能量特点,使用非扩髓双锁定胫骨髓内钉治疗开放性和/或不稳定型胫骨骨折可使外科医生获得较高的骨折愈合率(97%)且并发症最少。本系列研究中发现的低感染率表明,这种髓内钉在治疗闭合性和部分开放性胫骨骨折时可能具有特别的优势。