Gemmill J D, Lifson W K, Rae A P, Hillis W S, Dunn F G
Department of Cardiology, Stobhill General Hospital, Glasgow.
Br Heart J. 1993 Dec;70(6):503-6. doi: 10.1136/hrt.70.6.503.
To assess the clinical ability of general practitioners to decide to give thrombolytic therapy to patients with suspected myocardial infarction and to assess the contribution of the electrocardiograph (ECG) to this decision-making process.
7 practices on the North side of Glasgow and the coronary care unit of Stobhill General Hospital.
137 patients presenting with chest pain who required direct admission to the coronary care unit.
Agreement between the general practitioner's clinical decision to give thrombolytic therapy with or without reference to the ECG and the prescription of thrombolytic therapy in the coronary care unit.
The predictive accuracy of the general practitioner's assessment of the necessity for thrombolytic therapy was 71.5%. The ECG had no impact on the accuracy of this decision and there were problems with the recording and interpretation of the ECG. Clinical decision making was altered in six cases by the ECG: wrongly in four.
The diagnostic accuracy among general practitioners would result in some patients who did not have acute myocardial infarction being given thrombolytic therapy. In this study the ECG did not contribute towards diagnostic accuracy. Substantial improvement in both the recording and interpretation of ECGs is needed before thrombolytic agents can be routinely prescribed at home.
评估全科医生决定对疑似心肌梗死患者进行溶栓治疗的临床能力,并评估心电图(ECG)在这一决策过程中的作用。
格拉斯哥北部的7家诊所及斯托布希尔综合医院的冠心病监护病房。
137例因胸痛需直接入住冠心病监护病房的患者。
全科医生参考或不参考心电图做出的给予溶栓治疗的临床决策与冠心病监护病房实际给予溶栓治疗之间的一致性。
全科医生对溶栓治疗必要性评估的预测准确性为71.5%。心电图对该决策的准确性没有影响,且心电图的记录和解读存在问题。有6例患者的临床决策因心电图而改变:其中4例改变错误。
全科医生的诊断准确性会导致一些没有急性心肌梗死的患者接受溶栓治疗。在本研究中,心电图对诊断准确性没有帮助。在家庭中常规开具溶栓药物之前,需要大幅改进心电图的记录和解读。