Glanzmann C, Lütolf U M
Klinik für Radio-Onkologie, Universitätsspital Zürich, Schweiz.
Strahlenther Onkol. 1993 Aug;169(8):449-58.
Important studies of the therapy in patients with early stages of Hodgkin's disease aim at reducing the long-term risks, yet maintaining the high cure rate. Several prospective studies and two large meta-analyses did not observe a significant difference of the ten- or 15-year survival rate after radiotherapy or combined radio- and chemotherapy in the total group of patients with CS I/II A Hodgkin's disease, not withstanding a significant reduction of the recurrence risk after combined therapy. There is some evidence but no proof, that certain subgroups of patients with early stage, have a higher survival after combined therapy compared to that after radiotherapy alone. Most studies of therapy in Hodgkin's disease have a statistical power much too low, in order to demonstrate significant differences of the survival rate in the order of 10 to 15%. Randomized studies of chemo- versus radiotherapy in patients with PS I/II A and some PS III A have shown conflicting results. Patients with supradiaphragmatic Hodgkin's disease and CS I/II can be subdivided according to the recurrence risk after primary radiotherapy in the following subgroups: 1. Patients with a very low or a low recurrence risk of approximately 10 to 20%: patients less than 40 years old and CS I/II A NS/LP with less than three involved regions and no bulky mediastinal mass and an ESR below 30 mm. If there is only unilateral suprahyoidal lymph node involvement, primary radiotherapy of the involved region or a mini-mantle or a mantle field is acceptable and achieves a recurrence free survival of 90% or higher. If there is only non bulky mediastinal involvement, mantle field radiotherapy is acceptable and achieves a recurrence-free survival of at least 90%. In the other patients, primary irradiation of an extended mantle field without a staging laparotomy is an acceptable primary treatment, achieving a recurrence-free survival rate of approximately 80%. Another option is a staging laparotomy with splenectomy and a mantle radiotherapy for PS I/II. Few groups prefer primary chemotherapy alone or some type of a reduced chemotherapy with lesser toxicity combined with localized radiotherapy and long-term observations of a larger group of patients after the last type of treatment have to confirm the excellent early results. 2. Patients with an intermediate recurrence risk of approximately 20 to 40%: patients, who do not belong to group one or group 3.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
针对早期霍奇金病患者的治疗进行的重要研究旨在降低长期风险,同时维持高治愈率。几项前瞻性研究和两项大型荟萃分析并未观察到,在CS I/II A期霍奇金病患者的总体组中,放疗或放化疗联合治疗后10年或15年生存率存在显著差异,尽管联合治疗后复发风险显著降低。有一些证据但未经证实,即某些早期患者亚组在联合治疗后的生存率高于单纯放疗后的生存率。霍奇金病治疗的大多数研究的统计效力过低,无法证明生存率有10%至15%的显著差异。对PS I/II A期和一些PS III A期患者进行化疗与放疗的随机研究结果相互矛盾。膈上霍奇金病和CS I/II期患者可根据初次放疗后的复发风险分为以下亚组:1. 复发风险极低或低,约为10%至20%的患者:年龄小于40岁、CS I/II A NS/LP、受累区域少于三个、无巨大纵隔肿块且血沉低于30 mm的患者。如果仅单侧舌骨上淋巴结受累,受累区域的初次放疗或小斗篷野或斗篷野放疗是可以接受的,无复发生存率可达90%或更高。如果仅为非巨大纵隔受累,斗篷野放疗是可以接受的,无复发生存率至少为90%。在其他患者中,不进行分期剖腹手术的扩大斗篷野初次照射是一种可接受的初始治疗方法,无复发生存率约为80%。另一种选择是分期剖腹手术加脾切除术及PS I/II的斗篷野放疗。少数组倾向于单纯初次化疗或某种毒性较小的简化化疗联合局部放疗,最后一种治疗方式后对更多患者进行长期观察,以证实早期的良好结果。2. 复发风险中等,约为20%至40%的患者:不属于第一组或第三组的患者。(摘要截断于400字)