Klassen A C, Celentano D D, Weisman C S
Department of Health Policy and Management, School of Hygiene and Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Md.
Am J Public Health. 1993 Sep;83(9):1316-20. doi: 10.2105/ajph.83.9.1316.
The purpose of the study was to examine the efficacy of a Maryland law requiring Pap testing to be offered during hospital admissions. "In-reach" strategies emphasize cancer screening within existing health care contacts (such as inpatient stays) rather than additional visits solely for screening.
Data from a 1986 telephone survey of Maryland women were used to examine the effect of hospitalization on self-reported Pap testing in a 3-year period. The effect of hospitalization on screening was examined by age and income to assess whether inpatient screening was more prevalent among certain subgroups of women.
For the group as a whole, the odds of Pap screening did not vary with hospitalization. However, among women aged 45 to 54 years with annual household incomes over $20,000, hospitalized women were more likely than nonhospitalized women to report recent Pap tests. For low-income women aged 75 years and older, hospitalization actually decreased the likelihood of reporting Pap tests.
Despite legislation, inpatient cervical cancer screening appears to mirror outpatient patterns, leaving elderly and low-income women unscreened. Methods for increasing inpatient Pap testing for underscreened women are discussed.
本研究旨在检验马里兰州一项要求在住院期间提供巴氏试验的法律的效力。“深入服务”策略强调在现有的医疗接触(如住院治疗)中进行癌症筛查,而不是仅仅为了筛查而增加就诊次数。
利用1986年对马里兰州女性进行的电话调查数据,研究住院治疗对3年内自我报告的巴氏试验的影响。按年龄和收入对住院治疗对筛查的影响进行了研究,以评估住院筛查在某些女性亚组中是否更为普遍。
就总体而言,巴氏筛查的几率并未因住院治疗而有所不同。然而,在45至54岁、家庭年收入超过20,000美元的女性中,住院女性比未住院女性更有可能报告近期进行了巴氏试验。对于75岁及以上的低收入女性,住院治疗实际上降低了报告进行巴氏试验的可能性。
尽管有相关立法,但住院宫颈癌筛查似乎反映了门诊筛查模式,使得老年女性和低收入女性未得到筛查。本文讨论了增加对筛查不足女性进行住院巴氏试验的方法。