Lopez-Gil M, Brimacombe J, Cebrian J, Arranz J
Department of Anaesthesia and Reanimation, Maranon University Hospital, Madrid, Spain.
Anesthesiology. 1996 Apr;84(4):807-11. doi: 10.1097/00000542-199604000-00007.
A prospective study was conducted to determine the rate of skill acquisition with the laryngeal mask airway in pediatric anesthesiology practice. The aim of the study was to provide information about the amount of supervised training required before satisfactory levels of skill were achieved.
Eight anesthesia residents in their third year of training with no prior experience using the laryngeal mask airway were observed using the device in 75 pediatric patients each (600 patients in total). Residents were given standardized guidelines for laryngeal mask airway usage in accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations and followed a predetermined protocol for anesthetic management. Induction was achieved with propofol followed by either a propofol infusion or isoflurane and either controlled or spontaneous ventilation as clinically indicated. Predefined major and minor problems were documented during the induction, maintenance, and recovery phases of anesthesia by a randomly selected supervising consultant trained in the study protocol and problem definitions.
The total number of problems was 189 occurring in 121 children. Fifty-five children had one problem, sixty-four children had two problems, and two children had three problems. Of the problems, 77 were major and 112 were minor. The problem rate per patient for overall, major, and minor problems was 31.5%, 12.8%, and 18.7%, respectively. The problem rate comparing the first to last epochs of 15 uses decreased from 62% to 2% for overall problems, 23% to 2% for major problems, and 39 to 1% for minor problems. The residents with the most problems in the final epoch had problem rates of less than 10% after 60 uses. There was a significant decrease in the overall problem rate for induction, maintenance, and recovery (P < 0.05). The major problem rate decreased significantly for induction and maintenance (p < 0.05), but not for recovery. The minor problem rate decreased significantly for induction and recovery (P < 0.05).
This study confirms that there is a rapid improvement in laryngeal mask airway skills when the standard recommended technique is employed and that a low problem rate can be achieved within 75 uses. Pediatric anesthesiologists with problem rates greater than 10% should determine if they are using the device suboptimally.
开展了一项前瞻性研究,以确定在儿科麻醉实践中使用喉罩气道的技能习得率。该研究的目的是提供有关在达到满意技能水平之前所需的监督培训量的信息。
观察了8名处于培训第三年且此前无使用喉罩气道经验的麻醉住院医师,他们每人在75例儿科患者中使用该设备(总共600例患者)。根据制造商的建议,为住院医师提供了喉罩气道使用的标准化指南,并遵循预定的麻醉管理方案。采用丙泊酚诱导,随后根据临床指征进行丙泊酚输注或异氟烷麻醉,并采用控制通气或自主通气。在麻醉诱导、维持和恢复阶段,由一名经过研究方案和问题定义培训的随机挑选的指导顾问记录预先定义的主要和次要问题。
共有189个问题发生在121名儿童身上。55名儿童有一个问题,64名儿童有两个问题,2名儿童有三个问题。其中,77个为主要问题,112个为次要问题。总体、主要和次要问题的每例患者问题发生率分别为31.5%、12.8%和18.7%。比较15次使用的第一个时期和最后一个时期,总体问题发生率从62%降至2%,主要问题发生率从23%降至2%,次要问题发生率从39%降至1%。在最后一个时期问题最多的住院医师在使用60次后问题发生率低于10%。麻醉诱导、维持和恢复阶段的总体问题发生率显著下降(P<0.05)。诱导和维持阶段的主要问题发生率显著下降(P<0.05),但恢复阶段未下降。诱导和恢复阶段的次要问题发生率显著下降(P<0.05)。
本研究证实,采用标准推荐技术时,喉罩气道技能会迅速提高,并且在使用75次以内可实现低问题发生率。问题发生率大于10%的儿科麻醉医生应确定他们是否未充分优化使用该设备。