Hobbs F D, Delaney B C, Carson A, Kenkre J E
Department of General Practice, University of Birmingham, Medical School, Edgbaston, UK.
Fam Pract. 1996 Apr;13(2):133-7. doi: 10.1093/fampra/13.2.133.
This study aimed to assess the uptake and effect in primary care of a computerized decision support system (DSS) for the management of hyperlipidaemia.
A prospective controlled trial was conducted in 25 practices covering a population of 150,000 in the city of Birmingham. The Primed system, a specialist developed, rule based DSS for general practice, was introduced prospectively after a 3-month baseline data collection. The main outcome measures were nine months' data on prescribing of lipid lowering agents; use of laboratory tests; and referrals to secondary care for the investigation of hyperlipidaemia.
System use was lower than expected. A shift was observed towards requests for appropriate follow-up of previously abnormal lipid results and a greater emphasis on full lipid profiles, in line with the DSS guidelines. Referrals showed a 55% decrease on those expected (NS). The prescribing evaluation revealed a large variation between practices, but no significant alteration following system use. Views of users favoured decision support as a concept, but criticised technical problems with the system.
Greater integration of DSS software and practice based data handling systems is needed. The mode of data capture, and hence both the content and form of knowledge representation, in DSS must take greater account of the primary care consultation process if such systems are to be of use to practitioners.
本研究旨在评估用于高脂血症管理的计算机化决策支持系统(DSS)在初级保健中的应用情况及效果。
在伯明翰市25家诊所开展了一项前瞻性对照试验,覆盖人群达15万。在收集3个月的基线数据后,前瞻性引入了Primed系统,这是一种专门为全科医疗开发的基于规则的DSS。主要结局指标包括九个月内降脂药物处方数据、实验室检查使用情况以及因高脂血症调查而转诊至二级医疗机构的情况。
系统使用低于预期。观察到向对既往异常血脂结果进行适当随访的请求转变,并且更加强调完整血脂谱,这与DSS指南一致。转诊情况比预期减少了55%(无统计学意义)。处方评估显示各诊所之间存在很大差异,但系统使用后无显著变化。用户观点支持决策支持这一概念,但批评了系统的技术问题。
需要将DSS软件与基于实践的数据处理系统更好地整合。如果此类系统要对从业者有用,DSS中的数据捕获模式以及知识表示的内容和形式都必须更充分地考虑初级保健咨询过程。