Burri A T, Schumacher C F, Vorkauf H
Med Educ. 1977 Jul;11(4):276-84. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2923.1977.tb00610.x.
A test in Internal Medicine of the American National Board of Medical Examiners was given to Swiss medical students as a graduating examination. This study dealing with the feasibility of such an enterprise describes the technical procedures and investigates the problems of translation and the validity of foreign made items. Comparison of item analyses for the 369 Swiss candidates and for a sample of 370 American candidates reveals that most items are of close comparability in difficulty, discrimination and pattern of response to the distractors. In a cross-national comparison of student's responses to the items no systematic content characteristics can be found for items favouring one group or the other. Swiss experts, in judging the validity of the items for testing Swiss students, could indeed identify in advance some of the items that proved to be less valid and more difficult for their--but also the American--students. It is concluded that National Borad examination can be as valid and suited to examine Swiss candidates for licensure as it is to examine American candidates.
美国医学考试委员会的内科测试被用作瑞士医学生的毕业考试。这项关于此类考试可行性的研究描述了技术流程,并调查了翻译问题以及国外命题的有效性。对369名瑞士考生和370名美国考生样本的题目分析比较显示,大多数题目在难度、区分度以及对干扰项的反应模式上具有高度可比性。在跨国比较学生对题目的回答时,未发现有利于某一组学生的题目存在系统性的内容特征。瑞士专家在判断这些题目对测试瑞士学生的有效性时,确实能够提前识别出一些对他们自己的学生以及美国学生来说效度较低且难度较大的题目。研究得出结论,国家委员会考试对于考查瑞士考生获得执照的资格而言,与考查美国考生一样有效且适用。