Woodle E S, Bruce D S, Josephson M, Newell K A, Piper J B, Millis J M, Cronin D, Whitman G, Ruebe M, Thistlethwaite J R
University of Chicago, Section of Transplantation, IL 60637, USA.
Clin Transplant. 1996 Aug;10(4):323-32.
FK 506 has proven to be an effective immunosuppressive agent in liver transplantation, but its role in renal transplantation remains to be defined. Since the initial availability of FK 506 for treatment of refractory renal allograft rejection, we have applied an aggressive approach consisting of institution of rescue therapy at an early point in the rejection process combined with assiduous monitoring of FK 506 blood levels and the histologic response to therapy. A total of 17 adult patients were treated for refractory renal allograft rejection with this approach. Median follow-up was 9 months post-initiation of FK 506 therapy. Median time to first rejection was 26 d post-transplant, and median time to FK 506 rescue therapy was 113 d post-transplant. Sixteen of 17 patients received either ATGAM or OKT3 induction therapy. Prior to FK 506 rescue therapy, patients received the following antirejection therapy: corticosteroids 40 + 21 mg/kg (prednisone or Solumedrol), OKT3 (median 14 d), ATGAM (3 patients, 14 d each). FK 506 rescue therapy was successful in reversing the rejection process in all 17 patients. Fifteen patients (88%) demonstrated rapid reversal of rejection (i.e. reversal within 14 d), whereas three patients demonstrated delayed reversal. Nine month actuarial patient and graft survivals were 92% and 84%. When censored for documented noncompliance, nine month actuarial graft survival was 92%. Good long-term renal function was observed (pre-FK 506 baseline creatinine 2.1 +/- 0.5 mg/dl, current serum creatinine 2.1 +/- 0.6 mg/dl. Six recurrent rejection episodes occurred in 5 patients (29%) with a median time to recurrent rejection of 59 d post-initiation of FK 506 rescue therapy. Each recurrent rejection episode was successfully treated by corticosteroids and/or increased FK 506 dose. CMV disease and lymphoma were not observed. Histologic evidence of FK 506 nephrotoxicity (hyaline necrosis in preglomerular arterioles) was observed in 6 patients 30% (median time to diagnosis 49 d). FK 506 blood levels (whole blood TDX) between 10 and 20 ng/ml provided effective reversal in most patients. Current FK 506 dose and blood levels are 0.18 +/- 0.09 mg/kg/d and 7 +/- 2 ng/dl). FK 506 rescue therapy also allowed aggressive reductions in prednisone dose: (mean current prednisone dose 0.08 +/- 0.05 mg/kg/d). In conclusion, an aggressive approach toward FK 506 rescue: 1) provides prompt, effective reversal of refractory renal allograft rejection, 2) good long-term renal allograft function, 3) balanced immunosuppression with respect to recurrent rejection, opportunistic infection and PTLD, 4) acceptable toxicity, and 5) aggressive reduction in corticosteroid dosing. Based on these findings, FK 506 rescue therapy is now the treatment of choice in our program for renal allograft rejection episodes that occur following antilymphocyte antibody therapy.
FK506已被证明在肝移植中是一种有效的免疫抑制剂,但其在肾移植中的作用仍有待确定。自从FK506最初用于治疗难治性肾移植排斥反应以来,我们采用了一种积极的方法,即在排斥反应过程的早期实施挽救治疗,并同时仔细监测FK506的血药浓度以及治疗的组织学反应。共有17例成年患者采用这种方法治疗难治性肾移植排斥反应。FK506治疗开始后的中位随访时间为9个月。首次排斥反应的中位时间为移植后26天,FK506挽救治疗的中位时间为移植后113天。17例患者中有16例接受了抗胸腺细胞球蛋白(ATGAM)或OKT3诱导治疗。在FK506挽救治疗前,患者接受了以下抗排斥治疗:皮质类固醇40+21mg/kg(泼尼松或甲泼尼龙)、OKT3(中位时间14天)、ATGAM(3例患者,各14天)。FK506挽救治疗成功逆转了所有17例患者的排斥反应过程。15例患者(88%)的排斥反应迅速逆转(即14天内逆转),而3例患者的逆转出现延迟。9个月时患者和移植物的实际生存率分别为92%和84%。当排除记录在案的不依从情况时,9个月时移植物的实际生存率为92%。观察到长期肾功能良好(FK506治疗前基线肌酐2.1±0.5mg/dl,当前血清肌酐2.1±0.6mg/dl)。5例患者(29%)发生了6次复发性排斥反应,复发性排斥反应的中位时间为FK挽救治疗开始后59天。每次复发性排斥反应均通过皮质类固醇和/或增加FK506剂量成功治疗。未观察到巨细胞病毒病和淋巴瘤。6例患者(30%)出现了FK506肾毒性的组织学证据(肾小球前小动脉透明坏死)(诊断的中位时间为49天)。10至20ng/ml的FK506血药浓度(全血TDX)在大多数患者中提供了有效的逆转。当前FK506剂量和血药浓度分别为0.18±0.09mg/kg/d和7±2ng/dl。FK506挽救治疗还允许积极减少泼尼松剂量(当前泼尼松平均剂量0.08±0.05mg/kg/d)。总之,针对FK506挽救治疗的积极方法:1)能迅速、有效地逆转难治性肾移植排斥反应;2)长期肾移植功能良好;3)在复发性排斥反应、机会性感染和移植后淋巴组织增生性疾病方面实现免疫抑制平衡;4)毒性可接受;5)积极减少皮质类固醇剂量。基于这些发现,FK506挽救治疗现在是我们项目中抗淋巴细胞抗体治疗后发生的肾移植排斥反应的首选治疗方法。