White S J, McLean A E, Howland C
Lancet. 1979 Sep 1;2(8140):458-61. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(79)91505-8.
Over 2000 epileptic patients admitted to the Chalfont Centre for Epilepsy between 1931 and 1971 and taking anticonvulsants were followed up to the end of 1977. Mortality between 1951 and 1977 was greatly in excess of that in the general population of England and Wales in that period allowing for age and sex. Some of the excess was directly attributable to epilepsy, but there were also more deaths from suicide and circulatory, respiratory, and malignant disease than would be expected. Apart from the brain and central nervous system, no particular site had a significant excess of tumours. In particular, there were no liver tumours (and only one gallbladder carcinoma). This makes it unlikely that the liver tumours produced on feeding phenobarbitone to mice are indicators of major human risk.
1931年至1971年间入住查尔方特癫痫中心且正在服用抗惊厥药物的2000多名癫痫患者接受随访至1977年底。1951年至1977年间的死亡率大大超过了同期英格兰和威尔士普通人群的死亡率(已考虑年龄和性别因素)。部分超额死亡率直接归因于癫痫,但自杀以及循环系统、呼吸系统和恶性疾病导致的死亡人数也高于预期。除脑和中枢神经系统外,没有特定部位出现明显过多的肿瘤。特别是,没有肝肿瘤(仅有一例胆囊癌)。这使得给小鼠喂食苯巴比妥所产生的肝肿瘤不太可能成为重大人类风险的指标。