Kanter R K, Edge W E, Caldwell C R, Nocera M A, Orr R A
Department of Pediatrics, State University of New York, Health Science Center, Syracuse 13210, USA.
Pediatrics. 1997 Jan;99(1):59-63. doi: 10.1542/peds.99.1.59.
The Pediatric Risk of Mortality (PRISM) score is a measure of illness severity based on abnormalities observed in the bedside examination and laboratory assessment. PRISM scores obtained after pediatric intensive care unit (PICU) admission predict mortality probability, but no previous efforts to evaluate mortality risk before PICU admission have been reported. Our study was performed on patients admitted to PICUs at four pediatric tertiary care centers to derive a quantitative estimate of hospital mortality probability as a function of PRISM scores obtained at referring hospitals before PICU transfer. Performance of the model was tested by evaluating accuracy of mortality predictions obtained from pre-ICU PRISM scores in a separate validation set of patients.
Patients were randomized to the derivation or validation sets. Data were recorded prospectively from observations made at hospitals referring to the study PICUs. Patients included 780 infants and children with medical and surgical emergencies and trauma. Electively admitted patients were excluded from analysis.
The relationship between mortality probability (P) and the pre-ICU PRISM score is expressed by the equation: P = er/(1 + er). In this equation, r is an empirical function of the pre-ICU PRISM score: r = .197 x PRISM - 4.705. The mortality probability rises from near 0 at low scores, approaching 1 (certainty) above a PRISM score of 40. Mortality probability exceeds 10% at a score of 13 and exceeds 50% at a score of 24. Performance of predictions in the validation set of patients was evaluated for five categories of mortality probability. The observed number of deaths corresponded to predicted mortality across the range of illness severity. When compared for each tertiary institution, observed mortality rates were similar to predictions for three of four institutions. For data obtained at institution D, the observed mortality of 17% significantly exceeded the 7% predicted rate. In infants younger than 1 year, as well as children 1 year and older, observed mortality rates were similar to predicted.
The pre-ICU PRISM score as a measure of illness severity provides an estimate of hospital mortality probability. Further investigation is required to determine the use of pre-ICU mortality estimates in making clinical decisions.
儿童死亡风险(PRISM)评分是一种基于床旁检查和实验室评估中观察到的异常情况来衡量疾病严重程度的指标。儿科重症监护病房(PICU)入院后获得的PRISM评分可预测死亡概率,但此前尚无关于评估PICU入院前死亡风险的相关研究报道。我们对四家儿科三级护理中心PICU收治的患者进行了研究,以得出根据PICU转院之前在转诊医院获得的PRISM评分来定量评估医院死亡概率的方法。通过评估在另一组独立的验证患者中由ICU前PRISM评分得出的死亡预测准确性,对该模型的性能进行了测试。
将患者随机分为推导组或验证组。前瞻性记录来自转诊至研究PICU的医院的观察数据。患者包括780名患有内科、外科急症及创伤的婴幼儿和儿童。择期入院的患者被排除在分析之外。
死亡概率(P)与ICU前PRISM评分之间的关系由以下公式表示:P = er /(1 + er)。在此公式中,r是ICU前PRISM评分的一个经验函数:r = 0.197×PRISM - 4.705。死亡概率在低分情况下接近0,在PRISM评分高于40时接近1(确定性)。评分达到13时死亡概率超过10%,评分达到24时超过50%。针对五类死亡概率对验证组患者的预测性能进行了评估。在疾病严重程度范围内,观察到的死亡人数与预测死亡率相符。在对每个三级机构进行比较时,四家机构中有三家的观察死亡率与预测结果相似。对于在机构D获得的数据,观察到的17%的死亡率显著超过了预测的7%。在1岁以下的婴儿以及1岁及以上的儿童中,观察到的死亡率与预测结果相似。
作为疾病严重程度衡量指标的ICU前PRISM评分可对医院死亡概率进行估计。需要进一步研究以确定在临床决策中使用ICU前死亡风险估计值的情况。