Yazawa Y, Kitano H, Suzuki M, Kodama A, Kitajima K
Department of Otolaryngology, Shiga University of Medical Science, Ohtsu.
Nihon Jibiinkoka Gakkai Kaiho. 1996 Dec;99(12):1746-50. doi: 10.3950/jibiinkoka.99.1746.
Between 1978 and 1981, Feldmann's osteopathic approach was often used to manage chronic middle ear disease. In this procedure, the superior and posterior segment of the ear canal wall was cut after complete mastoidectomy, removed temporarily and re-positioned in the previous position after handling the diseased focus in the tympanic isthmus area. Forty-one cases (24 cases of non-cholesteatomatous chronic otitis media and 17 cases of cholesteatoma) were followed and long-term results of this procedure were studied with regard to re-operative findings following this procedure. Among the 41 patients, 13 (31.7%) required revision surgery because of cholesteatoma formation, infection etc. Seven of these 13 patients (53.8%) required revision surgery because of cholesteatoma formation after this procedure. None of these 7 cases appeared to involve residual cholesteatoma. The most important problem is that 3 of the 7 patients showing cholesteatoma formation had non-cholesteatomatous chronic otitis media before this procedure. In other words, the Feldmann's osteoplastic approach may iatrogenically induce cholesteatoma formation in non-cholesteatomatous chronic otitis media. The re-operative findings indicated that the re-positioned canal wall in this procedure may have small bony defects or bony erosion, inducing pocket formation through these defects to create a new cholesteatoma. Although recent literature concerning tympanoplasty recommends posterior canal wall reconstruction using cartilage, bone, ceramic material or bone-pate rather than the canal wall down method, careful follow-up should be continued with regard to pocket formation and/or cholesteatoma formation.
1978年至1981年间,费尔德曼的整骨疗法常被用于治疗慢性中耳疾病。在该手术中,在完成乳突切除术后,切开耳道壁的上半部分和后半部分,暂时移除,在处理鼓室峡部区域的病灶后重新放置回先前位置。对41例患者(24例非胆脂瘤性慢性中耳炎和17例胆脂瘤)进行了随访,并根据该手术后再次手术的结果研究了该手术的长期效果。在这41例患者中,13例(31.7%)因胆脂瘤形成、感染等原因需要再次手术。这13例患者中有7例(53.8%)在该手术后因胆脂瘤形成需要再次手术。这7例中似乎均未涉及残留胆脂瘤。最重要的问题是,这7例出现胆脂瘤形成的患者中有3例在该手术前患有非胆脂瘤性慢性中耳炎。换句话说,费尔德曼的骨成形术可能会医源性地在非胆脂瘤性慢性中耳炎中诱发胆脂瘤形成。再次手术的结果表明,该手术中重新放置的耳道壁可能存在小的骨质缺损或骨质侵蚀,通过这些缺损形成袋状结构,从而产生新的胆脂瘤。尽管最近有关鼓室成形术的文献推荐使用软骨、骨、陶瓷材料或骨粉进行耳道后壁重建,而不是耳道壁下翻法,但对于袋状结构形成和/或胆脂瘤形成仍应继续进行仔细随访。