Aviv J E, Sacco R L, Thomson J, Tandon R, Diamond B, Martin J H, Close L G
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center, New York, NY 10032, USA.
Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1997 Feb;106(2):87-93. doi: 10.1177/000348949710600201.
Dysphagia and aspiration are two devastating sequelae of stroke. Recent work has shown that laryngopharyngeal (LP) sensory deficits are associated with aspiration in stroke patients with dysphagia. The phenomenon of silent LP sensory deficits, where the patient exhibits no subjective or objective evidence of dysphagia, yet has an LP sensory deficit, has not been previously described. The aim of this study was to evaluate the sensory capacity of the laryngopharynx in stroke patients who had no subjective or objective complaints of dysphagia. We determined the sensory threshold in the laryngopharynx using air pulse stimulation of the mucosa of the pyriform sinus and aryepiglottic fold. Eighteen stroke patients (mean age 65.6 +/- 11.5 years) and 18 age-matched controls were prospectively evaluated. Normal thresholds were defined as < 4.0 mm Hg air pulse pressure (APP). Deficits were defined as either a moderate impairment in sensory discrimination thresholds (4.0 to 6.0 mm Hg APP) or a severe sensory impairment (> 6.0 mm Hg APP). Stroke patients were followed up for 1 year to determine the incidence of aspiration pneumonia (AP) as verified by chest radiography. In 11 of the stroke patients studied, either unilateral (n = 6) or bilateral (n = 5) severe sensory deficits were identified. The elevations in sensory discrimination thresholds were significantly greater than those in age-matched controls (7.1 +/- 0.6 mm Hg APP versus 2.5 mm Hg APP; p < .01, Wilcoxon score). Among patients with unilateral deficits, sensory thresholds were severely elevated in all cases on the affected side compared with the unaffected side (p < .01, Wilcoxon score). Moreover, the sensory thresholds of the unaffected side were not significantly different from those of age-matched controls. Aspiration pneumonia did not occur in the patients with normal LP sensation or in the patients with unilateral severe LP sensory deficits. However, in the 5 patients with bilateral, severe LP sensory deficits, 2 developed AP, both within 3 months of their LP sensory test. The results of this study showed, for the first time, that stroke patients without subjective or objective clinical evidence of dysphagia could have silent LP sensory deficits. These impairments could contribute to the development of AP following stroke. The findings in this study suggest that LP sensory discrimination threshold testing should not be restricted only to patients with clinical dysphagia.
吞咽困难和误吸是中风的两种严重后遗症。最近的研究表明,喉咽(LP)感觉功能障碍与吞咽困难的中风患者的误吸有关。无声LP感觉功能障碍现象,即患者没有吞咽困难的主观或客观证据,但存在LP感觉功能障碍,此前尚未见报道。本研究的目的是评估没有吞咽困难主观或客观主诉的中风患者的喉咽感觉功能。我们通过对梨状窦和杓会厌襞黏膜进行气脉冲刺激来测定喉咽的感觉阈值。前瞻性评估了18例中风患者(平均年龄65.6±11.5岁)和18例年龄匹配的对照者。正常阈值定义为气脉冲压力(APP)<4.0 mmHg。感觉功能障碍定义为感觉辨别阈值中度受损(4.0至6.0 mmHg APP)或严重感觉功能障碍(>6.0 mmHg APP)。对中风患者进行1年随访,以确定经胸部X线证实的误吸性肺炎(AP)的发生率。在研究的11例中风患者中,发现单侧(n = 6)或双侧(n = 5)严重感觉功能障碍。感觉辨别阈值的升高显著大于年龄匹配的对照者(7.1±0.6 mmHg APP对2.5 mmHg APP;p <.01,Wilcoxon评分)。在单侧感觉功能障碍的患者中,与未受影响侧相比,所有病例中受影响侧的感觉阈值均严重升高(p <.01,Wilcoxon评分)。此外,未受影响侧的感觉阈值与年龄匹配的对照者无显著差异。LP感觉正常的患者或单侧严重LP感觉功能障碍的患者未发生误吸性肺炎。然而,在5例双侧严重LP感觉功能障碍的患者中,2例在LP感觉测试后3个月内发生了AP。本研究结果首次表明,没有吞咽困难主观或客观临床证据的中风患者可能存在无声LP感觉功能障碍。这些功能障碍可能导致中风后AP的发生。本研究结果表明,LP感觉辨别阈值测试不应仅限于有临床吞咽困难的患者。