Klemi P J, Toikkanen S, Räsänen O, Parvinen I, Joensuu H
Turku University Central Hospital, Finland.
Br J Cancer. 1997;75(5):762-6. doi: 10.1038/bjc.1997.135.
In a population-based mammography screening, 129,731 examinations were carried out among 36,000 women aged 40-74 in the city of Turku, Finland, in the period 1987-94. Women older than 50 were screened at 2-year intervals, and those younger than 50 at either 1-year or 3-year intervals, depending on their year of birth. Screen-detected breast cancers numbered 385 and, during the same time period, 154 women were diagnosed with breast cancer outside screening in the same age group in the same city, and 100 interval cancers were detected. Two hundred and fifty (67%) of the screen-detected cancers were of post-surgical stage I compared with 45 (45%) of the interval cancers and 52 (34%) of the cancers found outside screening (P<0.0001). However, among women aged 40-49 the frequency of stage I cancers did not differ significantly among screen-detected cancers, interval cancers and cancers found outside screening (50%, 42% and 44% respectively; P=0.73). Invasive interval cancers were more frequent among women aged 40-49 if screening was done at either 1-year (27%) or 3-year intervals (39%) than in older women screened at 2-year intervals (18%; P=0.08 and P=0.0009 respectively). Even if adjusted for the primary tumour size, screen-detected cancers had smaller S-phase fractions than interval cancers or control cancers (P=0.01), but no difference in the S-phase fraction size was found between cancers of women younger than 50 and those older than this (P=0.13). We conclude that more interval cancers were found among women younger than 50 than among those older than 50 and that this could not be explained by the rate of cancer cell proliferation.
在芬兰图尔库市开展的一项基于人群的乳腺钼靶筛查中,1987年至1994年期间,对36000名40至74岁的女性进行了129731次检查。50岁以上的女性每两年筛查一次,50岁以下的女性根据出生年份,每年或每三年筛查一次。筛查发现的乳腺癌有385例,同一时期,在同一城市的同一年龄组中,有154名女性在筛查外被诊断出患有乳腺癌,还发现了100例间期癌。筛查发现的癌症中有250例(67%)为术后I期,而间期癌为45例(45%),筛查外发现的癌症为52例(34%)(P<0.0001)。然而,在40至49岁的女性中,筛查发现的癌症、间期癌和筛查外发现的癌症中I期癌症的发生率没有显著差异(分别为50%、42%和44%;P=0.73)。如果40至49岁的女性每年(27%)或每三年(39%)进行一次筛查,与每两年进行一次筛查的老年女性(18%)相比,侵袭性间期癌在她们中更为常见(分别为P=0.08和P=0.0009)。即使对原发肿瘤大小进行校正,筛查发现的癌症的S期分数也比间期癌或对照癌小(P=0.01),但50岁以下女性的癌症与50岁以上女性的癌症在S期分数大小上没有差异(P=0.13)。我们得出结论,50岁以下的女性比50岁以上的女性发现更多的间期癌,这无法用癌细胞增殖率来解释。