Tobach E, Skolnick A J, Klein I, Greenberg G
American Museum of Natural History, New York, NY 10024, USA.
Percept Mot Skills. 1997 Apr;84(2):355-70. doi: 10.2466/pms.1997.84.2.355.
Reports on self-recognition in great apes have been mostly derived from experimental studies of mirror behavior (mark test) requiring anesthetization of the animals. We investigated a relatively noninvasive technique to study this behavior. In two experiments with a group of captive orangutans (1 adult male, 3 adult females, 1 juvenile male, and 1 juvenile female), we presented combinations of blank posters, life-size portraits of each individual in the group, a mirror, and videos. Durations of viewing and patterns of viewing were recorded. The prominent features of the viewing were the differences among the individuals in frequency, duration, and pattern of viewing. Some evidence of mirror-based self-referent behavior (behavior in which the activity of the animal with its body was related to the activity of the image in the mirror) was seen in the juvenile female, but more was seen in one adult female. This adult female spent the most time viewing the mirror and was the only animal to view her own portrait more than the other portraits in one session. In addition, she moved from one portrait to another, and back to the first, and to her own portrait and the mirror in a pattern resembling comparison of the two portraits as well as of her portrait and her mirror image. It is suggested that data based on self-referent behavior of the same animal during self-viewing in a mirror and during viewing of its self-portrait and on behavior observed in the mark test are worth further investigation.
关于大猩猩自我认知的报告大多来自对镜像行为(标记测试)的实验研究,而这些研究需要对动物进行麻醉。我们研究了一种相对非侵入性的技术来研究这种行为。在对一组圈养红毛猩猩(1只成年雄性、3只成年雌性、1只幼年雄性和1只幼年雌性)进行的两项实验中,我们展示了空白海报、群体中每个个体的真人大小画像、一面镜子和视频的组合。记录了观看时间和观看模式。观看的突出特点是个体之间在观看频率、持续时间和模式上存在差异。在幼年雌性中观察到了一些基于镜子的自我参照行为(动物身体活动与镜子中影像活动相关的行为)的证据,但在一只成年雌性中观察到的更多。这只成年雌性花在看镜子上的时间最多,并且是在一次实验中唯一观看自己画像的时间超过观看其他画像时间的动物。此外,她从一幅画像移到另一幅画像,然后回到第一幅,再到她自己的画像和镜子,其模式类似于对两幅画像以及她的画像和镜像进行比较。有人认为,基于同一动物在照镜子时的自我参照行为、观看其自画像时的自我参照行为以及在标记测试中观察到的行为所获得的数据值得进一步研究。