Gibbs C P, Peabody T D, Mundt A J, Montag A G, Simon M A
The University of Chicago Medical Center, Illinois 60637, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1997 Jun;79(6):888-97. doi: 10.2106/00004623-199706000-00013.
We reviewed the cases of sixty-two patients who had had a subcutaneous sarcoma to determine the effect of tumor and treatment-related variables on the rates of survival and local recurrence. Fifty-nine (95 per cent) of the patients had had an operation at another hospital before being referred to us. Twenty-nine (47 per cent) of the sixty-two tumors were high-grade, forty-two (68 per cent) were small (five centimeters or less), and thirty (48 per cent) were malignant fibrous histiocytomas. We followed a treatment strategy that consisted of repeat excision with the goal of obtaining wide margins. Excluding thirteen patients who had had a palpable local recurrence at the time of presentation, twenty (49 per cent) of forty-one patients who had had a marginal excision at another hospital had microscopic residual tumor on repeat excision. At a median of fifty-six months after the repeat excision, fifty (81 per cent) of the sixty-two patients had been continuously disease-free, one had no evidence of disease, eight had died of the disease, and three had died of other causes. The five-year rate of disease-free survival was 85 per cent (fifty-three of sixty-two patients). There were three local recurrences, all in patients who had had a marginal resection. No recurrences were noted in patients who had had a wide local excision of the tumor or of the previous operative field. Multivariate analysis revealed that a large tumor (greater than five centimeters), a marginal excision, and adjuvant radiation therapy were associated with a worse prognosis. Excellent rates of survival for patients who have a subcutaneous sarcoma, including those who have a large or high-grade tumor and those who have residual tumor following a previous operation, can be obtained with carefully planned operative treatment alone. We recommend operative excision or repeat excision with wide margins because of the high prevalence of residual tumor. Size is the most important tumor-related factor, and the operative margin is the most important treatment-related factor. The additional value of adjuvant radiation therapy remains unproved.
我们回顾了62例皮下肉瘤患者的病例,以确定肿瘤及治疗相关变量对生存率和局部复发率的影响。62例患者中有59例(95%)在转诊至我院之前已在其他医院接受过手术。62个肿瘤中,29个(47%)为高级别,42个(68%)较小(5厘米或更小),30个(48%)为恶性纤维组织细胞瘤。我们遵循一种治疗策略,即进行重复切除,目标是获得广泛的切缘。排除13例就诊时可触及局部复发的患者,在其他医院接受过边缘切除的41例患者中,有20例(49%)在重复切除时发现有微小残留肿瘤。重复切除后的中位时间为56个月时,62例患者中有50例(81%)持续无病,1例无疾病证据,8例死于该疾病,3例死于其他原因。无病生存率的5年率为85%(62例患者中的53例)。有3例局部复发,均发生在接受边缘切除的患者中。在对肿瘤或先前手术区域进行广泛局部切除的患者中未发现复发。多因素分析显示,肿瘤较大(大于5厘米)、边缘切除和辅助放疗与预后较差相关。对于皮下肉瘤患者,包括那些患有大肿瘤或高级别肿瘤以及先前手术后有残留肿瘤的患者,仅通过精心规划的手术治疗即可获得优异的生存率。由于残留肿瘤的高发生率,我们建议进行手术切除或广泛切缘的重复切除。肿瘤大小是最重要的肿瘤相关因素,手术切缘是最重要的治疗相关因素。辅助放疗的附加价值尚未得到证实。