Chaisson C E, Zhang Y, McAlindon T E, Hannan M T, Aliabadi P, Naimark A, Levy D, Felson D T
Boston University Arthritis Center, Department of Medicine, Boston Medical Center, MA, USA.
J Rheumatol. 1997 Jul;24(7):1337-43.
Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common type of arthritis; involvement of joints in the hand is highly prevalent, especially in the elderly. Few data are available on the incidence of hand OA in men and women or on the association between OA in one hand joint with incidence in others.
We studied the cumulative incidence of radiographic hand OA in a population based group of men and women, and evaluated whether baseline OA in one joint affected OA rates in other joints in the hand. Study subjects were 751 members of the Framingham Study cohort, who had a baseline right hand radiograph taken in 1967-1969 (mean age 55+/-5.58) and followup radiographs 24 years later.
In those without OA at baseline, women had more incident disease than men in almost all hand joints, but the joints most frequently affected were the same in both sexes: the distal interphalangeal (DIP), followed by the base of the thumb, proximal interphalangeal (PIP), and metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joints. The MCP joint group was the only one in which the incidence in men was comparable to incidence in women. Prevalent OA in one or more joints in a row (e.g., MCP) markedly increased the risk of incident OA in other joints in the same row. Also, prevalent OA in one joint in a finger (a ray) increased the risk of incident OA in other joints in that ray. Prevalent OA in either DIP or PIP joints at baseline substantially increased the risk of incident OA in all other hand joints. Thumb base OA at baseline increased risk in MCP joints, and to a lesser extent, DIP and PIP joints.
Cumulative incidence was generally higher in women than men, baseline OA in one joint in a row markedly increased the risk of developing OA in other joints in the same row, and baseline OA in a joint in a ray similarly increased risk in that ray. Interphalangeal joint OA at baseline appeared to increase subsequent OA in all hand joints, baseline OA in the thumb was not as strong a predictor. This descriptive information on incidence of radiographic hand OA should generate new hypotheses about why OA affects hands in particular patterns.
骨关节炎(OA)是最常见的关节炎类型;手部关节受累非常普遍,尤其是在老年人中。关于男性和女性手部OA的发病率或一个手部关节的OA与其他关节发病率之间的关联,现有数据很少。
我们研究了一组基于人群的男性和女性中手部放射学OA的累积发病率,并评估了一个关节的基线OA是否会影响手部其他关节的OA发生率。研究对象是弗雷明汉研究队列的751名成员,他们在1967 - 1969年拍摄了基线右手X光片(平均年龄55±5.58岁),并在24年后进行了随访X光片拍摄。
在基线时无OA的人群中,几乎在所有手部关节,女性的新发疾病都比男性多,但两性中最常受累的关节相同:远端指间关节(DIP),其次是拇指基部、近端指间关节(PIP)和掌指关节(MCP)。MCP关节组是男性发病率与女性相当的唯一一组。连续一个或多个关节(如MCP)存在OA会显著增加同一排其他关节发生OA的风险。此外,手指(一条射线)中一个关节存在OA会增加该射线中其他关节发生OA的风险。基线时DIP或PIP关节存在OA会大幅增加所有其他手部关节发生OA的风险。基线时拇指基部OA会增加MCP关节的风险,在较小程度上也会增加DIP和PIP关节的风险。
累积发病率一般女性高于男性,连续一个关节的基线OA会显著增加同一排其他关节发生OA的风险,一条射线中一个关节的基线OA同样会增加该射线中发生OA的风险。基线时指间关节OA似乎会增加所有手部关节随后发生OA的风险,拇指的基线OA作为预测指标的作用没那么强。这些关于手部放射学OA发病率的描述性信息应该会产生关于OA为何以特定模式影响手部的新假设。