Ciray I, Aström G, Sundström C, Hagberg H, Ahlström H
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Uppsala University Hospital, Sweden.
Acta Radiol. 1997 Sep;38(5):890-5. doi: 10.1080/02841859709172431.
To evaluate the role of CT with and without clinical information as compared to CT-guided bone biopsy in the assessment of suspected bone metastases.
The study comprised 51 consecutive patients with suspected bone metastases who had undergone CT-guided bone biopsies with an eccentric drill system. CT of the targets, clinical information, and histopathology were scored separately as malignant, uncertain or benign. The results of CT alone and CT in combination with clinical information were compared to the results of histopathology.
Histopathology diagnosed 45/51 lesions (88%), 23 as malignant and 22 as benign. CT correctly depicted 17 of these 23 malignant lesions. The remaining 6 malignant lesions were CT-scored as uncertain (n = 5) or benign (n = 1). CT correctly depicted only 3 of the 22 benign lesions. The remaining 19 benign lesions were CT-scored as malignant (n = 2) or uncertain (n = 17). When uncertain CT scores were combined with clinical scores, the true-positive and true-negative results for malignancy increased from 44% to 82%.
In most cases, CT in combination with clinical information gives enough information about the nature-malignant or benign-of a skeletal lesion. In uncertain cases, diagnostic accuracy can be improved by means of CT-guided bone biopsy.
评估有临床信息和无临床信息的CT与CT引导下骨活检相比,在疑似骨转移评估中的作用。
本研究纳入51例连续的疑似骨转移患者,这些患者均接受了使用偏心钻系统的CT引导下骨活检。分别对靶区的CT、临床信息和组织病理学进行恶性、不确定或良性评分。将单纯CT结果以及CT与临床信息相结合的结果与组织病理学结果进行比较。
组织病理学诊断出45/51个病变(88%),其中23个为恶性,22个为良性。CT正确描绘了这23个恶性病变中的17个。其余6个恶性病变的CT评分为不确定(n = 5)或良性(n = 1)。CT仅正确描绘了22个良性病变中的3个。其余19个良性病变的CT评分为恶性(n = 2)或不确定(n = 17)。当将不确定的CT评分与临床评分相结合时,恶性病变的真阳性和真阴性结果从44%提高到了82%。
在大多数情况下,CT结合临床信息能够提供关于骨骼病变性质(恶性或良性)的足够信息。在不确定的情况下,通过CT引导下骨活检可提高诊断准确性。